x

Like our Facebook Page

   
Early Times Newspaper Jammu, Leading Newspaper Jammu
 
Breaking News :   Gautam Gambhir Survives Cancellation Scare, Poll Body Accepts Nomination | PM Modi is ''Pradhan Prachar Mantri'' : Priyanka Gandhi | Leh DEO inspects SVEEP in Trans-Singhe-la areas | Baramulla: Restrictions imposed around examination Centres | J&K records increasing trend of forest carbon: DG FSI | School Education Department inspects Private schools | Principal Secretary Industries & Commerce visits SICOP Udhampur | Prevention of beggary: DM Srinagar orders strict action against soliciting of alms at public places | Power shutdown | Sat directs ERA officials to take up restoration works in Jammu West | Communal polarization in elections has posed threat to democracy: Harsh | Non-filers of GST returns for 2 months to be barred from generating e-way bills from June 21 | Failed politician’ looking for alternative employment in Bollywood: Cong on PM’s chat with Akshay | 306 candidates contesting Lok Sabha Phase 4 election have assets worth Rs 1 crore and more | ED Summons Shabir’s Daughter In PMLA Case When She Was 5-Yr-Old | Thunderstorm disrupts normal life | Unhappy with marriage, wife Apoorva murdered Rohit Shekhar Tiwari while he was drunk | Twinkle Khanna replies to Modi's saara gussa remark: Not only does PM know I exist, he reads my work too | After Gautam Gambhir, Irfan Pathan wants to take the political plunge | 21 opposition parties move SC seeking counter check of 50% EVMs using VVPATs | Pak militant belonging to LeT arrested in Baramulla, paraded before media | Vehicle carrying perishable food items be exempted from N-H Ban: Shah Faesal | South Kashmir bled enough due to PDP’s surrender: G.A. Mir | Anti-corruption bureau arrests Patwari taking bribe | If even another Gandhi comes, AFSPA can't be repealed: Amit Shah to Rahul Gandhi | Mehbooba Mufti leads protest rally in Pulwama over suspension of LoC trade | Terror funding case: Delhi court extends separatist leader Yasin Malik’s custody till May 24 | No one ready to take over JeM leadership in Kashmir: Army | Three dead, 11 injured after minibus hit by landslide in Doda | 10 Jammu and Kashmir terrorists based in Pakistan involved in LoC trade: Officials | | 21 opposition parties move SC seeking counter check of 50% EVMs using VVPATs | Arrangements reviewed for upcoming Amarnath yatra in JK | Bhat demands setting up of NEET exam centers within state | Mehbooba Mufti leads protest rally in Pulwama over suspension of LoC trad | Body of 25-yr-old boy found under mysterious conditions in Doda | Terror Funding Case: Court sends Yasin Malik to judicial custody till May 24 | 10 JK militants based in Pak involved in LoC trade: officials | Opposition cries foul over EVM malfunction; to move Supreme Court again | Life returns to normal in Kashmir | Train service resumes in Kashmir valley | Fire damages 5 shops in Sopore town | Heritage School holds expert talk on cultural heritage | | ABS celebrates World Book day | Inter School zone level tournament of Hiranagar gets underway | GCW Parade organizes one day workshop | Stephens International Public School hosts 'Book Fair' | BGSBU conducts two days workshop | Various competitions held in U-14, U-17 inter-school championship | GDC students bid adieu to outgoing students | SSP Samba inaugurates Gym | 6 Scouts and Guide volunteers get Governor award | JU to get Major Research Boost- Prof Dhar | Parimpora Fruit Mandi traders to go on indefinite strike from Monday | Police Public meet oragnised at Arnia | Parimpora Fruit Mandi traders to go on indefinite strike from Monday | Right to franchise was snatched from KP migrants: Er. Rishi Kilam | DMEF appeals Governor for hassle free Darbar Move | Play "Mujrim Mai Nahi Par Mujrim Mai Hi Hu" staged in Natya Utsav | Bootlegger held, illicit liquor seized | Drug peddler arrested | Police-Public meet organised | 128 students of Jetking Jammu placed in various IT Companies | Team of doctors visit GMS Moutlian Kalan | Only Govt can provide free and quality education: JPSEIA | Traders in Kashmir demonstrate against shutting down cross-LOC trade | Mirwaiz's self made proposal for its political issue of J&K which not decided long ago | The decline and fall of the Congress | J&K records 13.63 % voter turnout in first leg of III Phase polls for Anantnag PC: Shailendra | Soz castigates decision to stop Cross-Loc trade | Kashmiri PhD scholar with alleged militancy links arrested in Punjab | Kashmir-based KPs seek quota in academic institutions | Home turf of Mehbooba Mufti saw 40 polling booths with zero votes | ECIs assurances over fool-proof security have fallen flat: G A Mir | Boycott will reward death, destruction: Omar to south Kashmir | JKHCBA elections: Sawhney releases Manifesto | Polling pattern all set to disturb Mehbooba's apple cart | 1.90% voter turnout in Bijbehara a bad omen for Mehbooba | Even neighbours reject PDP chief | Despite objections, surgeries done in Orthopedic OT in GMC&H | Cracks surface in separatists again, Hurriyat divided on hartal calls | Rs 45 cr spent, but Doda-Barath road in shambles | Cracks surface in separatists again, Hurriyat divided on hartal calls | Education Deptt responsible for dismal performance of govt schools in Class 8th exams | Trade, Education hit after RSS leader's killing | Indian Ambassador to Nepal meets Governor | Symposium, poster making competition organized | Book exhibition held | Inter school tournament for boys begins at Udhampur | IFBI Jammu places students in ICICI Bank | Scindia School, Gwalior to organize panel discussion on Positive Impact of Technology on Growing Children | Woman dead, two others injured in Poonch road accident | JCC deputation calls on Secretary R&R Deptt | Scindia School, Gwalior to organize panel discussion on Positive Impact of Technology on Growing Children | Budgam youth died due to electrocution in Baramulla | Enthusiasm missing in south Kashmir LS polls | Two residents of Kashmir permitted to cross LoC | Govt orders transfers, new postings of seven officers | Poonch locals demand bunkers inside schools along LoC | Protests mark polling by Kashmiri Pandits for Anantnag LS seat | My dad is not with me but his supporters are still there to ensure my win: Mehbooba | Municipal waste, garbage dumped into river | Hanging electric wires exposes SAUBHAGYA scheme of PDD | Blocked drains irk Samba people | J&K Bank inks MoU with NIT, Inaugurates refurbished BU' ATMs | NIA court discharges Kashmiri youth in Jalandhar case' | State Pensioners Association hold protest | Thakur Randhir Singh welcomes ban on cross LoC trade | LS Elections: Policeman Killed, 10 CRPF men, Govt employees among 20 Injured in Kokernag accidents | CEO discusses arrangements for Shri Amarnath Ji Yatra 2019 | Man gets lifer for murdering father | DIET Doda organizes orientation programme | Police book fraudsters for luring people, cop arrested | Cop, civilian dead due to electric short circuit | Mehbooba backers bash National Conference worker on poll day | Students of GMS Pharmanar protest against shortage of teachers | Stay dogs menace creates panic in Doda | Stinking garbage heaps create nuisance at Basohli, administration in slumber | KPs cast vote at special polling station in Udhampur | Elected Council, CEO MC, DDC Udhampur lack co-ordination, alleges social activist | Food safety team carries special drive | Back Issues  
 
news details
PSC's Rule 12 (B) violates RTI Act : CIC
Directs to provide copies of OMR sheets, Answer keys
12/6/2017 11:01:31 PM
Early Times Report

Jammu, Dec 6: Chief Information Commissioner (CIC) in its landmark judgment against Public Service Commission (PSC) has said that PSC's Rule 12 (B) directly violates J&K Right to Information Act especially section 19 wherein RTI Act has an overriding effect on all the laws which override J&K RTI Act 2009. CIC has further directed PSC to provide copies of OMR sheets and Answer keys to an information seeker under RTI….
Details available with Early Times reveals that an information seeker namely Maida Begum an aggrieved Assistant Professor candidate filed an RTI application on 21.02.2017 with the Public Information Officer (PIO), J&K, PSC seeking the following information:-
Answer key of Assistant Professor in Urdu discipline of written test held on 04.12.2016.
Photo copy of OMR of applicant of written test conducted by PSC on 04.12.2016 of Assistant Professor in Urdu discipline.
As she did not get reply within the stipulated time from the PIO, she filed First Appeal with First Appellate Authority (FAA) of PSC on 10.04.2017.
FAA also failed to dispose of her 1st Appeal as a result she approached the State Information Commission (SIC) in 2nd Appeal with the request that PIO may be directed for providing her the requisite information sought through her basic RTI application. SIC's 26.10.2017 order reads as :
"It is a fact that Section 19 of the J&K RTI Act, 2009 gives the RTI Act an overriding effect and states as under: " Act to have overriding effect- The provisions of the Act shall have effect notwithstanding anything inconsistent therewith contained in the State Official Secrets Act,Samvat.1977 (1) and any other law (2) for the time being in force or any instrument having effect by virtue of any law other than the Act".
The J&K RTI Act itself enumerates the grounds and situations in which information may not be provided and these are enumerated as exemptions under Sections 8 & 9 of the Act. Disclosure of Answer key after the result of the examination is announced doesn't seem to fall under any of the exemptions under Section 8 and certainly not under Section 9 which relates to copyright infringement.
Section 8(1)(e) exempts from disclosure of such ' information available to a person in his fiduciary relationship, unless the competent authority is satisfied that the larger public interest warrants the disclosure of such information'. OMR Sheets and the Answer key cannot be said to be held in fiduciary capacity by the examination conducting authority like the J&K PSC after the results of the examination have been finally announced. Such fiduciary relationship can be said to exist before the results are announced.
If the information pertaining to Answer scripts/OMR sheet and Answer key are continued to be held as secret and non-givable even after the results are out, then the aggrieved candidates will have nowhere to go to seek redressal.
Allowing inspection or providing a copy thereof of own OMR sheet without the Answer key is meaningless as there will be no way for the examinee/information seeker to evaluate or cross check his own performance and the marks. Moreover, if the policy of non-disclosure of OMR sheet and Answer key even after the results are announced on grounds like deletion of Rule 12(B) is continued, then the paper setters and the evaluators will also start feeling lack of accountability which situation is highly undesirable, against the transparency in the system and against the larger public interest. Since the J&K PSC is invoking deletion of Rule 12(B) of the J&K PSC conduct of examination Rules, 2005 as the reason for non-disclosure of the OMR sheet and Answer key even after the results are announced, then the very deletion of such Rule appears to be violative of Section 19 of the J&K RTI Act, 2009. Keeping in view the Supreme Court judgment above and the intent of Section 19 of the J&K RTI Act, 2009 and in terms of powers vested in the State Information Commission (SIC) under Section 16 of the Act, the PIO, J&K PSC is directed to provide a copy each of the OMR sheet of the appellant Maidah Begum and the Answer Key to the appellant as expeditiously as possible within a maximum period of 30 days from the date of receipt of this order, if the results have been announced. With these directions, this 2nd appeal filed before the State Information Commission is disposed of. The copy of Order be provided to the parties free of cost"
  Share This News with Your Friends on Social Network  
  Comment on this Story  
 
 
 
Early Times Android App
STOCK UPDATE
  
BSE Sensex
NSE Nifty
 
CRICKET UPDATE
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
   
Home About Us Top Stories Local News National News Sports News Opinion Editorial ET Cetra Advertise with Us ET E-paper
 
 
J&K RELATED WEBSITES
J&K Govt. Official website
Jammu Kashmir Tourism
JKTDC
Mata Vaishnodevi Shrine Board
Shri Amarnath Ji Shrine Board
Shri Shiv Khori Shrine Board
UTILITY
Train Enquiry
IRCTC
Matavaishnodevi
BSNL
Jammu Kashmir Bank
State Bank of India
PUBLIC INTEREST
Passport Department
Income Tax Department
JK CAMPA
JK GAD
IT Education
Web Site Design Services
EDUCATION
Jammu University
Jammu University Results
JKBOSE
Kashmir University
IGNOU Jammu Center
SMVDU