x

Like our Facebook Page

   
Early Times Newspaper Jammu, Leading Newspaper Jammu
 
Breaking News :   Beneficial Vedic Mathematics for children today | Social media should not have complete freedom. | FILES INSIDE, FAMILIES OUTSIDE: INDIA’S QUIET DIVIDE | World Witnessed India’s Might | Swift action, lasting impact: LG Sinha delivers justice to terror victim families | We are witnessing overwhelming atmosphere of spiritual fervor and festivity throughout base camps: LG | They should talk to us first: Omar’s veiled attack on Cong for unilaterally launching statehood agitation | 4 crore illicit cigarettes seized in six months, Rs 104 crore tax evasion detected | BSF raises ‘Drone Squadron’ for Indo-Pak Border | ED files prosecution complaint in Rs 5.59 cr bank fraud case | Heavy rain triggers flood-like situation in Rajouri | 4 Amarnath pilgrims injured in Ramban accident | Landslide blocks Jammu-Rajouri-Poonch highway | IMD issues flash flood alert for 12 J&K districts | CM Omar Abdullah advocates holistic implementation of National Education Policy | Div Com Jammu takes stock of damages, restoration works post torrential rains | ADGP Armed J&K felicitates wrestler Binyamin, Isaq for Winning Gold Medals | PIOCCI delegation calls on LG Kavinder in New Delhi | Two criminals detained under PSA in Kishtwar | E-Rickshaws not to ply on Highways, outside routes | High altitude destinations safe for visitors, pilgrimages in Doda: Police | University of Jammu selected under prestigious ANRF-PAIR programme | Rekha Mahajan meets Tarun Chugh | DC Bandipora chairs Road Safety meeting | Reasi Forest Division celebrates plantation drives | Agriculture must drive prosperity, not force migration: CM Yogi | DC Rajouri reviews preparedness of departments | NFR advances towards Digital Railway Network with New Auto Block Commissioning | DC Kishtwar reviews functioning of Revenue Department | Plantation drive by Vishwa Yog Sansthan held | Balbir extends heartfelt congratulations to BJP's new General Secretaries | ICAI - J&K Branch (NIRC) hosts seminar in India | Samba police apprehended 3 snatchers with sharp-edged weapon | The Principal District and Sessions Judge Ramban awarded life imprisonment two accused persons | Handicrafts & Handloom deptt Kashmir organizes CBP on Branding and Packaging | 70 Sanction letters handed-over to youth to generate employment | Bandipora Intensifies fight against drugs | JKCIP transforming ideas into impact: SKUAST-Jammu's AgriThon 2.0 begins | Samba police seizes 6 veicles including 4 dumpers for illegal mining | Desh Bhagat University hosts insightful webinar on “Food-Planet-Health” | Deepti jumps 10 places to 23rd in ODI batting ranking, Mandhana maintains top spot | Awareness Programme on POCSO Act held | BCCI will be covered in National Sports Governance Bill: sports ministry source | Durand Cup kicks off amid uncertainty in Indian football | DIG U-R Range Sarah Rizvi conducts security review meeting | Reasi Police continues action against drug peddlers | LG Ladakh pays obeisance at Gurdwara Sri Bangla Sahib | MLA Vikram Randhawa visits Satwari Cantonment area | Sakeena Itoo reviews functioning of Cluster University Srinagar | District Capex 2025–26 plan proposals reviewed | E-Commerce platforms urged to self-audit, eliminate dark patterns: Centre | Tangmarg craft dealer blacklisted, deregistered | Wildlife Division Kathua conducts plantation drive | Indian Army organises Ex-Servicemen widows conclave | Apni Party delegation meets Director FCS&CA raises Public Grievances | Mission Director JJM conveyed a meeting | We Care Welfare Society’s free fruit trees plantation drive | Special lecture delivered by expert from NCERT | Swedish Company Husqvarna organises awareness programme for Farmers | Swedish Company Husqvarna organises awareness programme for Farmers | DHS Jammu visits CHC Ramgarh District Samba | Back Issues  
 
news details
Book reveals secret talks and ‘Chenab Formula’ for J&K before Kargil war
7/19/2025 10:54:44 PM
Early Times Report

New Delhi, July 19: Weeks before the Kargil war erupted between India and Pakistan in 1999, the Atal Bihari Vajpayee and Nawaz Sharif governments discussed through back-channel talks a communal division of Jammu & Kashmir along the Chenab river — the “Chenab Formula” — as one of the solutions to the Kashmir issue, a new book has revealed.
According to Abhishek Choudhary’s biography “Believer’s Dilemma: Vajpayee and the Hindu Right’s Path to Power”, a series of secret back-channel talks were held between retired Pakistani diplomat and former high commissioner to India Niaz Naik and Indian interlocutor R K Mishra at a Delhi hotel following Vajpayee’s historic 1999 visit to Pakistan and the Lahore Declaration.
“In the last week of March 1999, Sharif’s emissary Niaz Naik… secretly checked into a Delhi hotel to pick up the threads with R. K. Mishra. Over the next five days, they discussed their impossible brief on Kashmir: a solution that was not just fair to all three concerned parties (one of them being the Kashmiris) but also practical to implement,” reads the book, which is the sequel to Choudhary’s award-winning bestseller “Vajpayee: The Ascent of the Hindu Right”.
With Vajpayee encouraging the duo “to innovate”, Mishra and Naik, after several rounds of trial and error, arrived at an “identifiable geographical boundary” as a border to partition J&K between the two countries — the “Chenab Formula”.
“(The formula) suggested by Naik, proposed giving areas to the west of the river, all Muslim-majority districts, to Pakistan; the ones to the east, all Hindu-majority, were to be retained by India,” it adds.
The discarded options included: “the LoC as the international border (rejected by Naik), autonomy for Kashmir (rejected by Naik), independence for Kashmir (rejected by Mishra), and a region-wise plebiscite (rejected by Mishra)”.
According to the book, before returning to Islamabad on April 1, Naik met Vajpayee, who sent a discreet message for Nawaz Sharif: “halt infiltration and cross-border shelling during the summer months”.
But that was not to be the case, and even as the secret diplomacy progressed, trouble was brewing. By early May, Indian intelligence and patrol units reported increased aggression along the Line of Control.
Later, alarmed by the situation, Vajpayee dispatched Mishra to Islamabad with a pointed message.
“On 17 May, an agitated R. K. Mishra alighted in Islamabad carrying Vajpayee’s deep hurt. He asked Sharif, point-blank, whether he had known about Kargil while signing the ‘Lahore Declaration’,” the book claims.
The ‘Lahore Declaration’, signed on February 21, 1999, by Vajpayee and Sharif, was a peace agreement between India and Pakistan aimed at improving relations and reducing the risk of nuclear conflict.
Ironically, it was May 17 — the very day when Vajpayee’s emissary questioned Sharif on Kargil — when the Pakistani premier received his “first briefing” on the Kargil operation.
“It was a selective briefing by the Kargil clique, presented without detailed maps, aimed to cajole Sharif into providing the government’s cover for the army’s private crusade,” the book adds.
While Pakistan’s foreign minister Sartaj Aziz and other officials were reportedly stunned, Sharif, who was swayed by “flattery” and “selective intelligence”, dismissed their concerns, remarking, “Sartaj Aziz sahib, can we ever take Kashmir through paperwork?” “With a tactical advantage from the strategic heights in Kargil, he (Sharif) advised the army to ‘take Allah’s name and keep this Operation going, this issue cannot be resolved through buses’,” it claims.
The Kargil War, also known as ‘Operation Vijay’, began in May 1999 and concluded in July with the Indian Army successfully pushing back Pakistani infiltrators from key positions.
On July 26, India declared victory after nearly three months of intense fighting in the icy heights of Ladakh’s Kargil region.
“Believer’s Dilemma”, priced at Rs 999, is described by publishing house PanMacmillan India as a political history of contemporary India covering the crucial period between 1978–2018 — “a transformative 40-year span that saw the Hindu Right move from the fringes into the corridors of power”. (PTI)
  Share This News with Your Friends on Social Network  
  Comment on this Story  
 
 
 
Early Times Android App
STOCK UPDATE
  
BSE Sensex
NSE Nifty
 
CRICKET UPDATE
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
   
Home About Us Top Stories Local News National News Sports News Opinion Editorial ET Cetra Advertise with Us ET E-paper
 
 
J&K RELATED WEBSITES
J&K Govt. Official website
Jammu Kashmir Tourism
JKTDC
Mata Vaishnodevi Shrine Board
Shri Amarnath Ji Shrine Board
Shri Shiv Khori Shrine Board
UTILITY
Train Enquiry
IRCTC
Matavaishnodevi
BSNL
Jammu Kashmir Bank
State Bank of India
PUBLIC INTEREST
Passport Department
Income Tax Department
JK CAMPA
JK GAD
IT Education
Web Site Design Services
EDUCATION
Jammu University
Jammu University Results
JKBOSE
Kashmir University
IGNOU Jammu Center
SMVDU