x

Like our Facebook Page

   
Early Times Newspaper Jammu, Leading Newspaper Jammu
 
Breaking News :   Power shutdown | Police patrol party attacked with grenade in Baramulla, two cops injured | Army jawan arrested on spying charges from Meerut Cantonment | World should thank us for eliminating terrorism: Pakistan Army spokesperson | Students from Kashmir need to submit 'no criminal record' certificate to study in Punjab | 3 terrorists killed, 1 police personnel martyred in Srinagar encounter, search on | Jammu, Ladakh expose PDP, NC's politics of competitive separatism | Tourism promotion in Jammu region, BJP's claims prove hoax | Failure to implement SLWM likely to cost JK govt Rs 650Cr | Inspecting sweet shops during festivals merely eye-wash | Amid #MeToo outrage, JK victims suffer as women commission is headless | Contractuals run the show in BGSBU Rajouri | Employees confused over Health Insurance Scheme | J&K Bank half-yearly net profit grows 44% to 146 Cr | GMS Satrari lacking infra, violating norms | Will Farooq Abdullah boycott Assembly poll too? | BJP- a house of satire politics | Towards Zero Hunger and Sustainability | Work on construction of Bunkers along IB stalled | Municipal polls culminate with dismal voter turn-out in Srinagar, Ganderbal districts | ZEO office functioning from private building for last 15 years | Construct bridge on Mendhar nallah | SDH Mandi faces staff shortage, patients suffer | NC, PDP shouldn't have boycotted JK civic polls: Guv | 2 absconders arrested | HC closes PIL, orders protection of artifacts | 9 yrs on, GREF fails to complete upgradation of Rajouri-Budhal road | HC grants 8 weeks for status report on recovering Gulmarg land | Infantry cycle rally to commemorate Infantry Day | Training imparted to counting staff in Rajouri | DEO holds meeting with candidates before counting of votes | Intera Diocesan Schools Sports Competition held | CTP on Commercial Organic Horticulture Organised | Cluster University holds first academic council meeting | Vyas deliberates on issues raised by trade, industrial bodies | Kumar for effective law enforcement to prevent, control pollution | IT raids MG enterprises, Rashtriya Industry, Janta industry in Jammu, Samba | TT Championship U-17 of Khelo India concludes | GDC Udhampur conducted Industrial visit | Shaheen FC, J&K Bank Academy reaches Final of Tournament | Youth Ramleela Natak Club stages Ramleela | MV Inlt' School celebrated World Food Day | vHarman dance institute organizes workshop on dance | APS Ratnuchak lift Khelo India Basketball | DGPC facilitates bicycler | Rajiv Gandhi College holds awareness rally on Swachh Bharat | Bovine smuggling bid foiled, 10 bovines rescued | Govt notifies 88 new services in 16 Departments under PGSA | Stolen bike recovered, two arrested | World Bank team to visit on Oct 22, review progress of JTFRP | Eight Sport climbers leave for Delhi for further coaching | Officers put on highest alert in view of bi-annual Darbar Move | JKHB removes encroachments on Channi park | 11 Munsiffs promoted as Sub-Judges | Scenes from Ramayana enthralled devotees | HC disposes of plea seeking Anantnag bypolls | 10 years jail to fraudster | Cent percent household electrification in J&K soon: Commissioner Secy PDD | Oil Tankers Assosciation calls for Indefinite strike | JPS celebrates 14th Annuals sports Day | DPS Jammu wins medals in TT tournament | Plus 2 lecturers for expediting regularization process of incharge incumbents | Div Com Jammu reviews progress of Dev Projects | 2 PHE officials suspended for negligence of duty | Water crisis in Kishtwar, Bhandari lambasts PHE Department | Teacher's JAC Thathri demands action against corrupt officials | NSUI prez quits after sexual harassment charges, Rahul Gandhi accepts resignation | Chairman JKGB Janak Raj Angural inaugurates new premises | Joint team inspects Private coaching Centres | SPA asks authorities to take steps against anti encroachment | 11 bovines rescued, smuggler arrested | AAP-J&K rejects suggestions of High Level State Committee | Govt clueless over laws governing Assembly suspension: Harsh | SSDF demands sedition case against Mehbooba | Mass protest of FMHWWA enters day 51 | ABVP celebrates World Food Day | JJSF starts fast on students martyr day | GMC surgery deptt to organize 7th annual conference | Documentary "Peering Souls and Peering Warriors" screened | Free dental camp organized by HelpAge India | MNP urges workers to gear up for Panchayat elections | JKMF demands release of salary to watch & ward employees of BSNL | Three Regional Councils only acceptable to all: MPEJ | KVK organizes certificate distribution camp | ABVP Jammu criticizes AMU students' act | GHSS Nagseni organized Industrial tour for IT students | 172 officials of Armed Police promoted in J&K | Back Issues  
 
news details
Suspension of Operations in Kashmir: A well intentioned move, but full of holes
Jaibans Singh5/17/2018 10:48:14 PM
The Union Government has declared "suspension of operations" in Kashmir during the holy month of Ramadan. A request for what was termed as a "ceasefire" was made by the chief minister of the state, Mehbooba Mufti, about a week back and the consent has come a few days before the visit of Prime Minister Narendra Modi to the state, which is slated for May, 19.
"I wholeheartedly welcome the Ramadan ceasefire and would like to thank @narendramodi ji & @rajnathsingh ji for their personal intervention," tweeted Mehbooba Mufti in response to the decision made public by the Home Ministry.
In a unique response, the decision has been welcomed by the National Conference too. "On the demand of all political parties (except the BJP, which had opposed it) the Centre has announced a unilateral ceasefire. Now if the militants don't respond in kind they will stand exposed as the true enemies of the people," tweeted Omar Abdullah, the National Conference Leader of Opposition in the state Legislative Assembly. His father, Farooq Abdullah, has also welcomed the move and congratulated Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Home Minister Rajnath Singh for taking this "great step forward."
It is notable that the BJP was not in favour of any such initiative at the time when the same was proposed by its coalition partner. "As long as there are terrorist activities in the valley, the security forces are duty bound to tackle it with utmost toughness. What is needed is terrorist activities should stop, operations would stop automatically. As long as terrorists are active in the valley, the security forces are duty bound to protect the citizens and the country," said Ram Madhav, National General Secretary of the BJP and in-charge of Jammu and Kashmir, in the wake of the unilateral ceasefire demand made by Mehbooba Mufti.
Comparisons of the initiative are being made with something similar that was done by the Atal Bihari Vajpayee led National Democratic Alliance (NDA) government in 2000. At that stage an initiative called Non Initiation of Combat Operations (NICO) was put into practice which, in effect, meant that operations against terrorists would cease in the holy month of Ramadan.
NICO was fuelled by an intense desire that Prime Minister Vajpayee nurtured to put an end to violence in Jammu and Kashmir. Notwithstanding the noble intentions, the policy failed to produce the desired results, despite being in place for five long months.
As an end result the number of terrorists operating in the state increased drastically, resulting in intense counter-terrorist operations in 2001 and 2002 by the security forces to neutralise the added numbers. Pakistan based terrorist organisations like the Jaish-e-Mohammad got an opportunity to invigorate their cadre and this led to the attack on the Indian Parliament, which took the two countries to the brink of War.
The NDA government and after that the UPA government learnt their lessons and subsequent requests for a ceasefire during Ramadan made by organisations like the Hizbul Mujahedeen were not acceded to. Now after 17 years, the clock has taken a complete turn; whether the initiative will bring about a better result this time round remains to be seen
The Indian Army had advised the government against taking the step in view of the past experience and the fact that terrorists' operational in the Valley have not shown any inclination to cease operations. The security forces are wary of a repeat of 2000, they hold a fear that the good work being done since early 2017 in elimination of terrorists will come to naught.
The first set back to the initiative came within hours of the same being announced with the terrorist outfit, Lashkar-e-Toiba (LeT), rejecting the same. LeT has termed cessation of operations as "treachery to the martyrs."
"Ceasefire is not an option. We deem it as sin to the sacrifices rendered in the freedom struggle. We are the heirs of martyrs and opting for such choice is treachery to their blood," said Abdullah Ghazanwi, spokesperson of LeT. Even as the announcement was being made terrorists opened fire on an Army Patrol in Shopian District of South Kashmir. This should serve as an indicator of things to come.
The only silver lining in the entire move is the permission given by the government to their security forces to react in self defence. The Ministry of Home Affairs has said that the security forces reserve the right to retaliate if attacked or if essential to protect the lives of innocent people.
But there is a catch here, this rule of engagement will, undoubtedly, be used by the paid supporters of Pakistan to pester and embarrass the security forces as and when they carry out an operation.
It is being said that the initiative will give Mehbooba Mufti the space to win back her isolated electorate. While such possibility exists the reverse can also happen. If the move fails the electorate will get further alienated
In trouble torn Kashmir an initiative that has a shelf life of only one month cannot be expected to produce far reaching results. Those who follow the path of terror, disruption and divisiveness will not get swayed by the same. They will, in fact, look upon it as an opportunity to strengthen themselves.
What Kashmir needed was some innovative, out-of-the-box ideas to leverage the holy month in pursuit of a lasting solution. A mass contact movement for weaning away the youth from the path of violence with involvement of leaders, civil society, parents, elders and religious teachers could have yielded better results. Security forces could have been tacitly told to go easy on operations and assist in the project with their own brand of Winning Hearts and Minds (WHAM).
Suspension of operations is a well intentioned albeit bold move taken by the government despite many not being in favour of the same. Surely, the decision would have been taken with full knowledge of the risks involved. There is, however, ample evidence based on past experience to establish that the security risk far outweigh the benefits that may accrue from such an initiative. One wrong move at this sensitive phase can take the clock back by many years. It would be best for the ruling dispensation to closely watch the Catch-22 situation that it has created.
  Share This News with Your Friends on Social Network  
  Comment on this Story  
 
 
 
Early Times Android App
STOCK UPDATE
  
BSE Sensex
NSE Nifty
 
CRICKET UPDATE
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
   
Home About Us Top Stories Local News National News Sports News Opinion Editorial ET Cetra Advertise with Us ET E-paper
 
 
J&K RELATED WEBSITES
J&K Govt. Official website
Jammu Kashmir Tourism
JKTDC
Mata Vaishnodevi Shrine Board
Shri Amarnath Ji Shrine Board
Shri Shiv Khori Shrine Board
UTILITY
Train Enquiry
IRCTC
Matavaishnodevi
BSNL
Jammu Kashmir Bank
State Bank of India
PUBLIC INTEREST
Passport Department
Income Tax Department
JK CAMPA
JK GAD
IT Education
Web Site Design Services
EDUCATION
Jammu University
Jammu University Results
JKBOSE
Kashmir University
IGNOU Jammu Center
SMVDU