x

Like our Facebook Page

   
Early Times Newspaper Jammu, Leading Newspaper Jammu
 
Breaking News :   'Pak paving way for pan-Islamist terror groups in Kashmir' | IAF can do all-weather bombing | Amid rising accidents, SRTC plan to start night service can prove 'disservice' | Kalakote BMO loses command over erring staff, people suffer | Now, PDP's north Kashmir leaders peeved at party | PDP's ex-MLC Firdous Tak, ors booked for 'hate speech' | Understand importance of elections, your vote: Munish to people | Will distribute my salary among needy' | Agents calling shots in ARTO office Samba | MPW suspended for corruption, release of payments under PMAY without construction of house | Missing J&K girl found in Punjab | DLSA Thatri organizes awareness programme | Major fire tragedy averted | Protection of Green Gold | 'We will vote for change, vote for Munish Gupta' | CB files chargesheet in financial fraud case in Poonch | Daily wagers, consolidated employees worried as Govt seeks details from Deptts | Yusmarg , Doodhpathri in shambles as CEO posts remain vaccant | SDH Tangmarg lacks facilities, needs permanent post of MS | Militancy in Kashmir would be wiped out soon: Rajnath Singh | Power shut down | Over dozen families without adequate water-supply since fortnight | TDF demands delimitation of assembly seats | Three day training programme concludes | Naveen Chowdhary inspects Cable Car Project at Patnitop¬† | 3 of family among 4 killed as SUV falls into Gorge in Ramban, 2 Critically Injured | MPEJ castigates PDP leader | ABVP activists stage protest outside DC Office | JYBT organizes "Shrimad Bhagwat Katha" | 3 Gamblers apprehended | NAS holds Mushaira | Public Grievances being redressed in time bound manner: Advisor Sharma | Demarcation with complete report to be completed within one week: DC Srinagar | DC constitutes committee to verify registered, to be registered cases of ISSS, NSAP schemes | Six pilgrims died in last 4 days, Amarnath Yatra toll reaches 22 | Fresh batch of 4,094 pilgrims leaves Jammu for Amarnath | DM constitutes District Level Content Monitoring Committee | Police arrest narcotic smuggler, recover 5.5 kg poppy straw | Annulling Articles 370, 35-A will tantamount to constitutional coup: Farooq Abdullah | Scouts & Guides Testing Camp of KVS begins | VC JU inaugurates "Asian Football Week" of Special Olympics Bharat | Madhav qualifies NET-JRF | Madhav qualifies NET-JRF | Madhav qualifies NET-JRF | Preeti qualifies NET | Najmus Saqib qualifies NET | Sunrise Public School organizes summer camp | JSSC's executive meeting organized | Inter-state championship begins at JU | Wildlife Department kick starts "Green J&K Drive" | JMC organizes plantation drive | Blood donation camp organized | Ramakrishna Mission Belur Math Adhyaksha visits SANJY Numwan Base Camp, offers medical aid for Yatries | Anti drug campaign by Excise department under CSR concludes | DC Jammu for timely completion of Mega Developmental Projects | Financial institutions can act as bridge between startups and innovation ecosystems: Advisor Skandan | High-level committee on Dal Lake calls on Advisor Sharma | Advisor Kumar reviews development, security scenario in Doda | Kansal reviews progress on externally funded infrastructure projects | JKNPP demands to restart Health centre in Ramnagar villages, stage protest | Retired Police personnel stage protest demonstration | JKTF holds protest, demands regular remuneration for SSA head teachers | Div Com reviews progress of CS schemes under power sector | Lady 'fraudster' denied bail | KPC demands Rs 15 lakh compensation for Pandita's family | Azad asked leaders to pull up their sleeves | Rape accused escaped from Police custody during treatment | Kidnapped minor girl recovered, accused nabbed within 6 hours | HC grants 3 weeks to file ATR | Court rejects bail of bovine smuggler | Naib Sarpanch injured as guns roar along LoC in Poonch | Expiry medicine seized in Mendhar, offender on run | Insanitation, dilapidated roads irk residents of Nanak Nagar Sec-11 | Back Issues  
 
news details
Congress cannot absolve itself from responsibility of dividing Bharat in 1947
8/22/2018 11:30:29 PM
Ravinder Jalali

"India, which is also
called Bharat, would have remained a united country if Jinnah had become the first prime minister", the 14th Dalai Lama said in Goa some days back. He was speaking at an event organised by Goa Institute of Management. "Mistakes always happen. Now, look at India. I think Mahatma Gandhi ji was very much willing to give Prime minister ship to Jinnah. But Pandit Nehru refused," he said. "Pandit Nehru, I know very well, was a very experienced person, very wise, but sometimes mistakes happen." He was answering a question asked by a student on how to "make sure we don't take wrong decisions due to our emotions while making these choices." Dalai Lama is living in exile in India since he fled Chinese forces in 1959. It may be his perception but not a statement of fact. He may not be in know of the basics of 1947 partition and it was a just a casual remark and may not deserve any attention other than the academics of it. The debate over who were responsible for the Partition, which led to the creation of the dominions of India and Pakistan, has been raging on for many years now. It is under this shadow I thought of putting partition of India in a perspective.
If we will go into deeper dimension of the Partition which includes the role of Muslim League as well as Congress, it will not be fair to blame squarely Congress for partition but for obvious reasons, Muslim League as well as British, were responsible for it. Although Britain had no stake in the partition because of being outsiders and knowing that it hardly matters for them because they are the outsiders and are not going to settle in India but for Muslim League and Jinnah it was a bounty with power and money. Does it mean that Jinnah can not be held responsible for Partition? Absolutely, No. It was he (Jinnah) who sowed the seed of partition on the basis of the religion and is the main culprit. The letter of Jinnah to Gandhi dated September 17, 1944, is a testimony to it which read as under:
"Muslims and Hindus are two major nations by any definition or test of a nation. We are a nation of a hundred million, we are a nation with our own distinctive culture and civilization, language and literature, art and architecture, names and nomenclature, legal laws and moral codes, customs and calendar, history and traditions, aptitudes and ambitions-in short we have our own distinctive outlook on life and of life. By all cannons of international law we are a nation."
The demand for Pakistan was based on the homeland concept. It was meant to be a separate homeland for protecting the Muslims. It is here pertinent to mention that neither Jinnah nor any resolution of the Muslim League ever suggested that a separate state was needed because Islam was in danger. However, some Muslim League leaders made religion-oriented speeches in the per-independence period and Islamic slogans were raised by the Muslim League in order to build support for itself in the 1946 provincial elections.
The role and responsibility of Congress in dividing Bharat and creation of Pakistan, a country founded on an idea of religious identity of Muslims is also of great significance and can not be ignored. It seems quite logical to infer that it is the Congress who can be also held responsible for creation of Pakistan on the basis of the fact that when Congress claims itself as a champion of freedom struggle and the main architect of Indian independence, then it should claim itself as cause of creating Pakistan. Pakistan is a bye-product of gaining India's Independence.
If we will go through one of the videos of former Justice of Pakistan Supreme Court and son of poet Iqbal, Dr. Javed Iqbal who clearly states that that Muslims are not capable of creating nation. If we will go by Cabinet Mission Plan there was a concept of Autonomy with in Indian union which Jinnah also accepted.
If today somebody is raising a demand for freedom or autonomy or something, it does not mean that he will get it unless it is given to them and it is the giver who is responsible for it. If in today's scenario, e.g. some separatists are demanding freedom, does it mean that we should give it? When slogans in JNU are raised which are anti -India or the demands are anti-national, but we did not accede to their demands. Similarly some separatists in Kashmir, backed by Pakistan are demanding cessation or freedom from India, does it mean that we should grant them, No. Then how demand of Muslim League for creation of Pakistan for Muslims could be granted? Who acceded to their request? Now it will be argued that the British is responsible for dividing India, but why Congress accepted the two nation theory on the basis of religion and in a hurry. It simple means that they negotiated and compromised the freedom of India by giving a portion of India to Pakistan.
If Muslims succeeded in getting their Pakistan where they feel free to practice Islam and will be Islamic country governed by Islamic rules, then what about the other faiths? Then obviously the areas other than Pakistan should have been for the rest of the faiths only, which is not. What I feel that it was Hindu Mahasabha an organisation of Hindus who vehemently opposed the creation Of Pakistan on the basis of religion.
Congress can not absolve itself by saying that it was British who divided India but then why they accepted the freedom? We can not say that Congress has achieved or fought for freedom, but was offered by British on the condition that the country will be divided between Muslims and Hindus. We could have continued with our fight for freedom for the whole of India, for further more periods. Congress can not plea that it would have taken longer period or the country could not have got freedom so early. It seems that congress was very eager to get power rather than the freedom of country. Had they been fighting sincerely for freedom of their mother land, and then they would not have accepted the partition no matter what Jinnah or Muslim league would have demanded, if going through the events of history and the freedom struggle
Those who say that Muslim League fought for independence of India are not correct. They never fought for independence but for Islam and caliphate. It was during popular Khilafat movement in Turkey for retaining the caliphate, protests emerged across the Muslim world, the most prominent activities took place in India and Muslims support for the caliphate. To its founders and followers, the Khilafat was not a religious movement but rather a show of solidarity with their fellow Muslims in Turkey. They aimed to build political unity amongst Muslims and use their influence to protect the caliphate. In 1920, they called upon the British to protect the caliphate and for Indian Muslims to unite and hold the British accountable for this purpose. After the victory of Mustafa Kemal's forces, which overthrew the Ottoman rule to establish a secular republic in independent Turkey and abolished the role of Caliph and sought no help from Indians, the Khilafat leadership fragmented on different political lines. They played a major role in the growth of the Muslim League's popular appeal and the subsequent Pakistan movement.
  Share This News with Your Friends on Social Network  
  Comment on this Story  
 
 
 
Early Times Android App
STOCK UPDATE
  
BSE Sensex
NSE Nifty
 
CRICKET UPDATE
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
   
Home About Us Top Stories Local News National News Sports News Opinion Editorial ET Cetra Advertise with Us ET E-paper
 
 
J&K RELATED WEBSITES
J&K Govt. Official website
Jammu Kashmir Tourism
JKTDC
Mata Vaishnodevi Shrine Board
Shri Amarnath Ji Shrine Board
Shri Shiv Khori Shrine Board
UTILITY
Train Enquiry
IRCTC
Matavaishnodevi
BSNL
Jammu Kashmir Bank
State Bank of India
PUBLIC INTEREST
Passport Department
Income Tax Department
JK CAMPA
JK GAD
IT Education
Web Site Design Services
EDUCATION
Jammu University
Jammu University Results
JKBOSE
Kashmir University
IGNOU Jammu Center
SMVDU