x

Like our Facebook Page

   
Early Times Newspaper Jammu, Leading Newspaper Jammu
 
Breaking News :   Students of JNVS B’la asked to resume class work | Return Form GSTR-B to be furnished electronically by Sept 20 | Advisor Sharma reviews status of NRDWP, ongoing PHE schemes | Jammu and Kashmir's division encourages demand for small states | IGP Jammu reviews security scenario on the eve of Janamashtami | Div Com Jammu reviews progress on land acquisition | Advisor Kumar lays foundation stone of 300 bedded GMC Hospital | Samba admin to focus on promotion of Bamboo cultivation, craft | DC Jammu chairs DDMA meeting | Ramban administration establishes Phone booths for public | To defame classmate, girl sends vulgar messages via fake Facebook profile; arrested | Court sends P Chidambaram to five-day CBI custody | Sonia Gandhi, Rahul Gandhi, Shashi Tharoor among top Congress leaders who are out on bail | Jammu IGP reviews security scenario ahead of Janmashtami | To defame classmate, girl sends vulgar messages via fake Facebook profile; arrested | Advisor Khan listens to public at Governor’s Grievance cell | Governor condoles demise of IGP Pani’s mother | Governor places Rs. 5 crore per district to Kick-start Back to Village works | Bhim Army chief Chandrasekhar Azad, supporters detained for violence during Ravidas temple protest | Rajnath Singh, Air Chief Dhanoa to receive first Rafale jet in September | PM Narendra Modi to embark on two-day state visit to France; counter-terrorism, defence top on agenda | Politicians cut to size: new J&K Govt to have 9 Ministers only | Registration of vehicles by Transport deptt runs at snail's pace | In Kashmir’s commercial hub a shopkeeper shows way to support Modi's decision | Employees wear casuals, fearing for stone pelters | Situation being monitored across all the places: DIG Central Kashmir | Ex BJP MLAs mull countering their probable replacements | J&K govt grants MoS status to mayors of Jammu and Srinagar | Residents of Ashram Road Sunderbani without power supply for 10 days | Governor places Rs 5 crore per district to Kick-start Back to Village works | New dawn awaits Jammu: Munish to people | Will distribute my salary among needy' | MP Tsering Namgyal in discussion with Union ministers for development in Ladakh | DB grants time to State for filing report | LeT militant killed in Baramulla encounter | Aftermath of Article 370's abrogation; Bathindi Traders concerned over immediate losses, hopeful of bright future | Kashmir Rail project: Div Com asks Reasi, Ramban DCs to resolve bottlenecks, land cases | Mirchi shopping Carnival spread smiles among Monika Super Market customers | New health warnings on tobacco products packs from Sept 1 | No immediate plan to withdraw troops from J&K: Union Minister | Higher penalties for traffic rule violations from September 1 | Day-time relaxations continue in Kashmir; students stay away from schools | Pakistan's ISI planning to carry out terror attacks in J&K to draw international attention | Massive outreach by Governor; advisor to hold open hearing in Srinagar ahead of Friday prayers | Jammu man duped of Rs 60 lakh by cyber fraudsters, case registered | Terror-funding: Court sends ex-J&K MLA Rashid Engineer to judicial custody | After peace prevails, all political activists released in Kishtwar, Govt shifts focus on developmental activities | AMSI takes up Industrial issues with Principal Secy I&C | Hal Sashti celebrated with religious fervor | DSSP wings demand immediate restoration of 'Dogra Certificate' | Plantation drive conducted | Sat inaugurates newly constructed lanes at Ward 41 | J&K: "Experts" should take back seat; let the people decide their future course | No third party intervention on Kashmir | Reorganisation of J&K and revocation of Article 370 & 35-A is an internal matter of India | Mayor tours old Jammu city areas | AHD organises plantation drive | Jammu industry facing financial crunch, claims BBIA | AOI demands extension in GST return filing date | 2 day BLOs training regarding special summary revision held | DYM appeals for larger participation in Lord Krishna Shobha Yatra | DYSS organises Inter Zone District Level Tournament | VRS given SRTC workers stage protest demonstration | DC Ramban conducts public outreach programme at Gool | Advisor Sharma to meet public on August 23 | Director CAD visits sub division Sarore | DDC Rajouri holds public outreach camp | Tugga Biradari congregation on August 25 | ICLAF celebrates Birth Anniversary of Rajiv Gandhi | KCSC A thrashes KCSC B by 17 runs | Inter School Chess Competition organized at Shiksha Niketan | Don't take people of Jammu region for granted, Harsh warns Union | DDC reviews formulation of MGNREGA convergence plan | BOMIS organizes career guidance and counselling session | Guest Lectures organized at YCET | House arrest of leaders attempt to gag voice of opposition: Indu Pawar | Anti drug rally flagged off at GDC Udhampur | Civilian killed in heavy mortar shelling by Pak army along LoC | Some Balmiki families had PRC in year 1957, says Kavinder Gupta | DPS Jammu excels in Inter-DPS Table Tennis Competition | State, Centre behaving like dictators: DCC | Pakistan violates ceasefire in Sunderbani sector | Labour Ministry plans to set up office in J&K: Gangwar | Cong leaders condemn eviction of Azad from Jammu Airport | Natrang' artist receives NUBKYSNA award | Athletes from J&K will now get better facilities: Marry com | BJP defends restrictions in state after revocation of special status | Article 370 scrapped, now a proposal to make Jammu & Kashmir a religious hub | PCCF reviews functioning of Forest department in Jammu | Prof Gupta hails PM's bold move | 80 separatists from J&K to be shifted to Karnal jail | MPEJ castigates Congress' dilemma over Article 370 | Power shut down | TDF welcomes abrogation of Article 370 | Sale of nylon thread for kite flying banned | PDD to hold Bijli Adalat on Aug 31 | AIBCU criticizes Congress for 'indiscipline' | Traders Federation demands extension of filing GST return | BJP gears up for organisational polls in Jammu & Kashmir | 2 drug peddlers held, contraband capsules seized | Back Issues  
 
news details
Rafale case: SC poses queries on waiver of sovereign guarantee, no tech transfer
5/10/2019 9:01:41 PM


New Delhi, May 10
The Supreme Court Friday posed searching questions to the Centre on its deal with France to buy 36 Rafale fighter jets on issues like the "waiver of sovereign guarantee" and the absence of technology transfer clause in the IGA pact.

The top court reserved its verdict on pleas, including the one filed by former Union ministers Yashwant Sinha, Arun Shourie and activist lawyer Prashant Bhushan, seeking review of its December 14 judgement which gave clean chit to the Centre's Rafale deal to procure jets from the French firm, Dassault.

A bench headed by Chief Justice Ranjan Gogoi referred to a judgement in the Lalita Kumari case which said that an FIR is must when information revealed commission of cognizable offence. "The question is whether you are obliged to follow the Lalita Kumari judgment or not."

Attorney General K K Venugopal told the bench, also comprising Justices S K Kaul and K M Joseph, that "there has to be a prima facie case, otherwise they (agencies) cannot proceed. The information must disclose commission of cognizable offence".

Justice Joseph referred to the earlier deal and asked the Centre as to why the inter-governmental agreement (IGA) on Rafale with the French administration does not have the clause of transfer of technology.

"The court cannot decide such technical aspects," the law officer said.

On the court's question of waiver of sovereign guarantee by France in the IGA and its replacement with a letter of comfort, Venugopal said it was not an "unprecedented practice" and referred to such agreements with Russia and the US where there was such a waiver.

"It is a question of national security. No other court in the world will examine a defence deal on these kinds of arguments", he said.

The bench was hearing three review petitions filed by the trio, a lawyer Vineet Dhandha and AAP lawmaker Sanjay Singh.

The apex court had said in the December verdict that there was no occasion to doubt the decision-making process in the procurement of 36 Rafale fighter jets and dismissed the petitions seeking an investigation into alleged irregularities in the Rs 58,000 crore deal.

At the outset, Bhushan submitted that the judgement did not deal with the prayer seeking probe into the deal and decided the petition on the premise that it was seeking cancellation of IGA.

He said the Centre misled the court by referring to non-existent CAG report in November, 2018 hearing when it is on record that the report came later in February this year.

"How did the government anticipate even before the CAG report came that the pricing details of Rafale will be redacted. In a report submitted in November 2018, how did they know that the CAG report in February next year would redact pricing details," the lawyer asked.

Bhushan alleged suppression of material facts from the court by the Centre and said that as many eight critical clauses of the standard defence procurement procedure were dropped in the deal in the meeting of Cabinet Committee on Security in September 2016.

One of the clauses dealt with the aspect that the government can cancel the deal if the information of any involvement of middleman comes to the light, he said.

"This is shocking that the government concealed this piece of information from the court. Doing away with the anti-Corruption clauses and concealment of this fact from the court is by itself a sufficient ground to order a criminal investigation," he said.

He referred to the news articles and said that three experts of Indian Negotiation Team (INT) had also raised the the objections to the inflated pricing of the aircrafts.

"The bench-mark price was firm and fixed. It was 5 billion Euros. But the final price for Rafale jets shot up to 55.6 per cent above the bench-mark price and would continue to increase with time," he alleged.

Referring to reports, he alleged that besides the seven member INT, which was negotiating the deal, "parallel negotiations" were undertaken by the PMO and this weaken the negotiating powers of the INT.

"Even the NSA was playing some role although he was not to be involved," he said.

"Anil Ambani was involved in this deal right from the beginning" and he even produced a film for the wife of a French leader, he said, alleging "quid pro quo" which required criminal investigation.

Shourie also addressed the bench on a separate plea seeking perjury prosecution of unknown government officials for misleading it during the hearing of the pleas.

Venugopal vehemently opposed the submissions and sought dismissals of the review petitions saying that the basic grounds of these pleas were the same as in the main case.

"The Supreme Court has already decided the challenge to the Rafale deal. I would still say that the petitioners are seeking review of the judgment on the basis of secret stolen documents," he said.

He then referred to a clause 10 of the IGA between France and India and said that it mandated maintaining the secrecy of the deal.

Venugopal then referred to the CAG report and said that it has been found that the government got the jets at 2.86 per cent lower price.

The government is under obligation to put defence material under cover, he said, adding that "when the security of the country is involved, you do not view it as a contract to build a highway or a dam".
  Share This News with Your Friends on Social Network  
  Comment on this Story  
 
 
 
Early Times Android App
STOCK UPDATE
  
BSE Sensex
NSE Nifty
 
CRICKET UPDATE
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
   
Home About Us Top Stories Local News National News Sports News Opinion Editorial ET Cetra Advertise with Us ET E-paper
 
 
J&K RELATED WEBSITES
J&K Govt. Official website
Jammu Kashmir Tourism
JKTDC
Mata Vaishnodevi Shrine Board
Shri Amarnath Ji Shrine Board
Shri Shiv Khori Shrine Board
UTILITY
Train Enquiry
IRCTC
Matavaishnodevi
BSNL
Jammu Kashmir Bank
State Bank of India
PUBLIC INTEREST
Passport Department
Income Tax Department
JK CAMPA
JK GAD
IT Education
Web Site Design Services
EDUCATION
Jammu University
Jammu University Results
JKBOSE
Kashmir University
IGNOU Jammu Center
SMVDU