x

Like our Facebook Page

   
Early Times Newspaper Jammu, Leading Newspaper Jammu
 
Breaking News :   SMC under scanner for 'sabotaging' bad weather preparedness | Pak-sponsored terrorists continue to play dirty games in Kashmir | Will new committee make skeletons tumble out of closets? | Patients administered expired Saline at DH Udhampur | Components of SBM scheme still await implementation in JK | CHC Basohli, Trauma Centre Mahanpur become showcase | Killings' on hilly roads going unabated; authorities are not ready to implement guidelines | Lt Governor reviews School Education, progress of languishing projects and Department of Prisons | Extra money to carry cell phones, cameras inside country's largest underground aquarium in Jammu irks tourists | Munshi escaping transfer last 6 yrs, continues to occupy city PP | Speaker J&K Legislative Assembly meets Lt. Governor | 4 RDD officials suspended for misappropriating funds | 4 died, 5 injured after vehicle carrying Mata Sarthal Devi pilgrims meets with accident | Lt. Governor sanctions Rs 1 lakh ex-gratia for NoK of deceased persons | People confused on working style of GREF | HMVs to ply from Jammu to Srinagar, LMVs both sides on highway | Shopkeeper shot dead by unidentified gunmen in Tral | Lt. Governor accords sanction for establishment of Contingency Fund | Azad expresses concern over road accidents in Doda | The Performers- NGO organises annual programme | KNIT celebrates 550th Prakash Utsav of Shri Guru Nanak Dev Ji | J&K UT GPB celebrates Guru Nanak's Birth Anniversary | SKUAST-Jammu organises ten-day training programme | GMC Jammu organises lecture on "DRUG ABUSE" | 'Unitum Paceum'- 2019 concludes at Heritage School | Natrang artist attends 'Mahesh Bhat Ki Pathshala' | IDPS Kathua celebrates Gurupurav | Painting competition on World Diabetes Day organised | State Dance Championship 2019 to be held in Dec | Chief Secretary reviews implementation of various social security schemes | Div Com reviews winter preparedness in Ramban, Doda, inspects shelter sheds | Parkash Purab of Guru Nanak Ji celebrated at Gurudwara Baba Chanda Singh Ji | Jhiri Mela: Agriculture Deptt stalls main attraction for visitors | 8 days first-aid training concluded | JK SLSA awarded Zonal Best in North Zone | Free medical camp organised to mark 550th Prakash Utsav of Guru Nanak Dev Ji | National education day celebrated at SMVDU | MVIS organizes career counselling session | Write-up on Poonch people released | MAM college wins by 6 wickets | Dangal organized at Bantalab | PMA organising Jammu Star Award | SPMR College celebrates Guru Nanak Dev Ji birth anniversary | Prospects of nuclear threat between India and Pakistan | Farooq Sahib! Hai Na Hamare Baap Ka | High profile women protest against abrogation of Articles 370 and 35-A | Chingus Fort should be preserved: Anita Thakur | Cycle of fatal accidents must end: Raman Suri urges Lt Gov | BSF, CISF recruitment rally for youth held | SAD(B) appeals Lt Governor to consider their demands | Signs of normalcy back in Kashmir after heavy snowfall | Tourists enjoy early snowfall in Nathatop | TCP Surankote to Jogi road in dilapidated condition | IRDAI releases text of proposed regulations | Lawyers' strike continues to affect work in District Court Bhaderwah | DDC inspects patient care at SDH Sunderbani | JKSAC hails Union Govt’s decisions | DDC Udhampur reviews progress on Devika project | JMC seals illegal structure | President CCI meets Lt. Governor | ABVP holds protest outside civil secretariat | Contractual lecturers, TA criticise HED order | JKNPP terms Speaker's continuation as unconstitutional | Revival of terrorism in Kishtwar requires thorough probe: Brig Gupta | J&K, Ladakh likely to witness snowfall, rains today onwards | Only 9.37pc of Rs 120.96 cr approved Budget spent on agriculture | After Karnah Keran road reopens, Machil, Gurez still closed | DB seeks personal appearance of Chairman BOPEE | India retaliates after Pakistan violates ceasefire along LoC | DM Jammu bans transportation of bovine animals | JNV invites online applications for admission to IX class | Power shutdown | Back Issues  
 
news details
Service book not a public document, says SIC
'It can't be obtained under Right to Information Act'
7/6/2019 11:57:27 PM
Early Times Report
jammu, July 6: The State Information Commission (SIC) has held that a copy of service book cannot be obtained under Right to Information Act (RTI) as the same is not a public document.
The Commission gave this judgment while hearing an appeal filed by a Kishtwar resident who intended to seek details of his brother, an employee of the Revenue department, under the RTI Act.
The Commission has directed the Assistant Commissioner Revenue (ACR) Kishtwar (PIO in DC Office) to provide copy of appointment order under RTI which was also denied earlier.
Details available with Early Times reveal that one Jaffer Hussain, of Gudhian, Kishtwar, filed an RTI application dated 21.08.2018 before PIO in the office of DC Kishtwar. Jaffer sought service details of his brother Arshad Hussain The information sought included copy of academic qualification, service book, appointment order, date of birth certificate, etc.
On non-receipt of information from the PIO, the appellant filed First Appeal before the First Appellate Authority, that is, ADC, Kishtwar, on 22.09.2018. Feeling aggrieved Jaffer filed Second Appeal before the SIC on 29.10.2018 (admitted on 06.02.2019) praying therein that requisite information, free of cost, may be provided to him.
The appeal came up for hearing before the Commission on 30.05.2019. The appellant was not present. However, the respondents (FAA/PIO) were present during the hearing. The respondents submitted that the applicant is the brother of Arshad Hussain, whose information has been sought by him. Arshad has been appointed on compassionate grounds under SRO-43 of 1994 on the death in harness of his father who was working as Girdawar in the Revenue department. The appellant has a property dispute with his brother, and in order to settle personal scores he used the provisions of the J&K RTI Act, 2009 for seeking information that was personal to the third party.
Giving chronological events in the disposal of the RTI application and the First Appeal filed by the appellant, the FAA (ADC Kishtwar ) and the PIO (ACR Kishtwar) submitted that after receipt of the RTI application, the process in terms of section 11 of the J&K RTI Act, 2009 was conducted and the views of the third party namely Arshad Hussain were sought with regard to disclosure or otherwise of the information sought by the appellant. The said third party objected to the disclosure of his personal information to the appellant. Accordingly, the information was refused.
Subsequently, the appellant filed First Appeal in the office of DC, Kishtwar on 22.09.2018 which was received on 23.09.2018. The FAA (ADC Kishtwar) told SIC that he issued three notices to the appellant on 04.10.2018, 15.10.2018 and 22.10.2018 to appear before him for presenting his case and disposal of the appeal. However, the appellant as per FAA/ADCs statement never turned up during the dates of hearing communicated to him.
Finally, the FAA/ADC, Kishtwar disposed of the appeal on 09.11.2018 by holding that the information sought by him was exempted from disclosure under section 8 (1)(i) of the J&K RTI Act, 2009 in light of the judgement of High Court of Madhya Pradesh dated: 01.02.2010 passed in Writ Petition No. 13646 of 2009 holding that personal information like details of family, service book and annual confidential reports of a third party are exempted from disclosure as the said information has no relationship to any public activity and if parted with, will certainly lead to the unwarranted invasion of the privacy of a government servant.
The appeal filed by the appellant was partly allowed and the PIO/ACR, Kishtwar was directed by Information Commissioner M A Mir to provide a copy of the first appointment order of his brother along with the entries regarding qualification and date of birth recorded in the service book or as is available in the personal file of Arshad Hussain within a period of 15 days from the date of receipt of the order.
The Commission however said that information sought by the appellant through points 3 to 9 of his RTI application cannot be provided, as the same is personal protected information of the third party and the disclosure of such information would cause unwarranted invasion in the privacy of said third party. With these observations and directions, the second appeal filed by the appellant before the SIC was disposed of by SIC.
  Share This News with Your Friends on Social Network  
  Comment on this Story  
 
 
 
Early Times Android App
STOCK UPDATE
  
BSE Sensex
NSE Nifty
 
CRICKET UPDATE
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
   
Home About Us Top Stories Local News National News Sports News Opinion Editorial ET Cetra Advertise with Us ET E-paper
 
 
J&K RELATED WEBSITES
J&K Govt. Official website
Jammu Kashmir Tourism
JKTDC
Mata Vaishnodevi Shrine Board
Shri Amarnath Ji Shrine Board
Shri Shiv Khori Shrine Board
UTILITY
Train Enquiry
IRCTC
Matavaishnodevi
BSNL
Jammu Kashmir Bank
State Bank of India
PUBLIC INTEREST
Passport Department
Income Tax Department
JK CAMPA
JK GAD
IT Education
Web Site Design Services
EDUCATION
Jammu University
Jammu University Results
JKBOSE
Kashmir University
IGNOU Jammu Center
SMVDU