Like our Facebook Page

Early Times Newspaper Jammu, Leading Newspaper Jammu
Breaking News :   Hartal dying fast in Kashmir after JK becomes UT | Poor teenager purchases smart-phone on instalments, police takes it forcibly | Bidders allege GMC Doda alters rules | Farooq, Omar, Mehbooba likely to be shifted to Jammu | GOI provides concession to students of community in academic, technical institutes | JK still shown as state on Government websites | Aspirants sleep on streets to beat 2 hours deadline for submission of applications | Top posts in Sheep Husbandry Deptt vacant, staff without salary | Dwivedi for 100% coverage under Beneficiary Centric Schemes | Ghulam Nabi Azad on three-day Jammu visit from Wednesday | Gurpurab celebrated with religious fervour | Dogri film shooting 'Mouj Masti' begins | Sanjeev Sharma brings laurels to Air Jammu | Natrang's Dogri play 'Bawa Jitto' spell bounds thousands in Jhiri Mela | Winners of J&K specially-able Judoka team felicitated | BGSBU celebrates National education day | Nine-day Jhiri Mela begins in Jammu | KVK Reasi organises campaign on seed treatment | NGO distributes plant saplings | BMS delegation calls on DC, Assistant Labour Commissioner | JKNPP appeal President to call meeting with JK leaders | JKMF appeals PM to intervene in salary issue of BSNL employees | MJR-47 appeals Lt Governor to address issues of refugees | Sikhs demand nomination of minority commission | JKNPP celebrates birth anniversary of Guru Nanak Dev | Federal Bank felicitates old age people | P L Gupta, Deva meet Lt Governor | Surrender yourself to Sadguru: Madhu Param Hans | SBBDT organizes Sadbhawna Yatra | Women Club Meri Pehchan organizes 'Maharaja Hari Singh Samman' | JU faculty members, Research Scholars meet Dr Kiran Bedi | Dwivedi for 100% coverage under Beneficiary Centric Schemes | Inclement weather forecast: DC Srinagar reviews preparedness | ABVP stages dharna outside Civil Sectt; raises charter of demands | Minor dies after speeding truck runs him over, locals demand justice | Massive combat ops in Kashmir by forces have broken back of terrorist organisations | 1503 bunkers complete, work on remaining in full swing | 6 year old raped, killed | Cold wave continues in most parts of J-K | Samba police recover kidnapped minor girl | Doda Accident: all 17 passengers boarded in vehicle killed | Srinagar-Baramulla rail service resumes after three month | Pak violates ceasefire along LoC | Traffic resumes on Jammu-Srinagar highway, Mughal road remains closed for 7th day | Flight Services at Srinagar Airport, Low Visibility Causes Delay in Operations | Kupwara-Karnah road reopens, Keran, Machil Gurez still cut off | 15 years on, Aishmuqam Shopping complex awaits completion | Unidentified militant killed in Ganderbal, search operation on | No official available in tehsil headquarters of Mankot, Balakot | Union Jt Secy Culture terms Kashmiris as ardent readers of good literature | AJKLTF demands separate education commission for JKUT | PHE EJF demands disbursement of wages | VC SKUAST Jammu meets Lt Governor | Justice Kumar visits Bal Ashram, Nari Niketan at RS Pura | India settling conflicts to move on path of progress: Raman Suri | AYUSH Medical Camp held at Gai Dessa | Congress, NC, PDP responsible for UT Status: TDF alleges | NOC from Traffic, Municipality sheer harassment to Private Schools: MPEJ | NOC from Traffic, Municipality sheer harassment to Private Schools: MPEJ | Teenager mauled to death by leopard | KPOA welcomes Ayodhya verdict | Back Issues  
news details
Court directs further investigation in DA Case
ACB files closure report after 22 years
10/18/2019 10:12:16 PM
Early Times Report

JAMMU, Oct 18: In much publicized disproportionate assets case against Deputy Director Food & Supplies registered by then Vigilance Organization Kashmir now Anti-corruption Bureau, the closure report was filed.
Additional Special Judge Anticorruption Kashmir RN Wattal after considering the closure report observed that matter requires further investigation in light of the points raised in order. Same therefore, compels this court not to accept the final report and same is accordingly returned to SSP VOK in terms of section 173 (8) of CrPC for further investigation of the case with the direction to the SSP VOK to get the matter investigated by an officer not below the rank of DySP and conclude the investigation within a period of three months from the receipt of this report.
The final report owes its origin to the FIR No. 88/1997 offence u/s 5(2) PC Act registered on written complaint lodged by General Secretary Peoples Welfare Forum against Shabir Ahmad Kanth the then Deputy Director (Admn) Food and Supplies Department Kashmir having misappropriated huge amount of government money by corrupt and illegal means in league with Mohammad Ashraf Shantoo Assistant Director, Iftikhar Banday, Additional Director Ghulam Nabi Shigan, A.A.O Mehraj-ud-din Khan Transport Officer, Khursheed Alam and Fayaz Ahmad Store Keepers of Food and Supplies Department and also having accumulated huge assets disproportionate to his known source of income in shape of 60 kanals of land that include 10 kanals at Bye-pass and 50 kanals at Hazratbal and bank accounts/deposits outside state at Delhi and Bangalore.
It is also alleged that accused was a partner of Shamiyana Restaurant at Boulevard at Srinagar, and also purchased Bungalows at Greater Kailash Delhi, Gandhi Nagar Jammu. It is also alleged that Deputy Director concerned in league with other staff members sold the food grains in black market and also fixed rates of transporters on higher side. Further it is alleged that the FCI was sending hundred to two hundred trucks of food grains on daily basis to valley and only 60% of these food grains used to reach valley and 40% of out of the same was being sold in black market. About 30 lacks of gunny bags were sold by the accused by taking recourse to fire incident at Gulab Bagh Godown.
The investigation commenced and during investigation statements of witnesses were recorded. It is observed in the report that the allegations being multifarious constrained the investigating agency to investigate the matter outside the State and restricted itself only to the receipt and dispatch of the food grains. It also transpires from the final report that assets of accused were verified from revenue agencies and allegations were found baseless. As regards the bank accounts outside in Delhi and Bangalore same could not be verified. The accused was not found the partner of the Shamiyana Restaurant and misappropriation of the 50% of the food grains was found to be wrong. In the operative part of report it reveals that the allegations in the FIR were not substantiated and investigation in the case was closed as not proved.
Court observed that the complications involved in the investigations of the case with multifaceted allegations and its ramifications outside the state constrained the investigating agency to restrict investigation to the checking of receipt and dispatch of food grains only." Additional Sessions Judge Anticorruption Kashmir RN Wattal observed that the casual and mechanical way of investigation is obvious and crystal clear from the observation of I.O in the final report itself. Multifaceted allegations though a challenge does not construe and impediment in the investigation of the case. It was not a big thing for VOK being a prime and professional investigating agency in corruption cases in the State. Moreover, what could have been ramifications in the investigating the case outside the State does not transpire from the report. Same is an exhibition of lame excuse with a conscious mind that can lead to an adverse inference. Another aspect of the case is that property of the accused that he was having during check period has not been investigated thoroughly as the report is silent about the same. The property in the shape of residential buildings in Delhi, Bangalore and Jammu that the accused was having has not been investigated as the final report is silent about the same. The allegations against other officers have not been thoroughly investigated as it revealed from final report and send back to ACB for further investigation. (JNF)
  Share This News with Your Friends on Social Network  
  Comment on this Story  
Early Times Android App
BSE Sensex
NSE Nifty
Home About Us Top Stories Local News National News Sports News Opinion Editorial ET Cetra Advertise with Us ET E-paper
J&K Govt. Official website
Jammu Kashmir Tourism
Mata Vaishnodevi Shrine Board
Shri Amarnath Ji Shrine Board
Shri Shiv Khori Shrine Board
Train Enquiry
Jammu Kashmir Bank
State Bank of India
Passport Department
Income Tax Department
IT Education
Web Site Design Services
Jammu University
Jammu University Results
Kashmir University
IGNOU Jammu Center