Like our Facebook Page

Early Times Newspaper Jammu, Leading Newspaper Jammu
Breaking News :   Hundreds of vehicles leave Jammu for Srinagar on Kashmir highway, Mughal road shut | Truck used to ferry terrorists crossed Lakhanpur fortnight before encounter | Parra’s arrest creates ripples in PAGD | Azad’s outburst sends Cong high command into tizzy | Over 400 teachers without salary since two months | J&K awaits Animal Welfare Board | COVID-19 recovery rate in JK reaches 93.57%; 489 new cases, 12 fresh deaths | Court pulls Police for framing businessman in fake case | Maintaining neutrality; fairness of election process to be ensured: Sinha | Para arrested by NIA on baseless charges, alleges Mehbooba | 4 injured in Minibus skids on road | 25 facilities being set up under first phase of project: DC Srinagar | Mahajan appeals KP migrants to ensure maximum participation in poll process | COVID Vaccine | AFTER PAKISTAN’S DEADLY DIWALI GIFTS TO J&K, IT NEEDS MORE SURGICAL STRIKES | Feminine face of women exploitation | Pakistan army should shed its irrational anti-India strategy | Munish Gupta asks government to solve problems of people of ward 45 lane 5 Rani Talab Digiana | SSP Traffic Jammu interacts with civil society in Gujjar Nagar | PM holds 33rd PRAGATI video-conference with Chief Secretaries | Ahmed Patel will be remembered by variety of people: Soz | LIC employees stage protest demonstration | Lowered interest rates, orders auction of defaulters’ properties | GDC Billawar organizes series of events | Mukti NGO urges govt to simplify life certificate procedure | PTA lifts overall trophy | GDC Ramnagar organises online session on Personality Development | NCC Volunteers celebrates Flag Day | BBIA lauds financial relief to industrial sector | Corporator Sahil Gupta Welcomed Anurag Thakur | AJKLTF delegation call on Advisor to LG | Shiksha Niketan organises “Online Slogan Writing Competition” | BJP announces list of DDC candidates for Kishtwar | Final randomization of polling staff for 1st Phase held at Ramban | Mechanism in place to ensure transparent, peaceful elections in JK: SEC Sharma | Junaid Mattu elected as Srinagar Mayor | MD, SFC takes Major Decisions, interest rate lowered down | Jandial Biradari annual ‘Mail’ cancelled | BJP Chief Lambasts PDP For Maintaining Links With Terror Outfits As NIA Arrests Para | Sky is the limit for Horticulture production: Navin Choudhury | Several public deputations, individuals call on Advisor Bhatnagar | Dozens of far-flung, remote areas remain cutoff in north Kashmir | Two forms rejected, polling station for phase 3rd notified in Kupwara | Annual congregation of Patyar Biradari cancelled | Women Club Meri Pehchan felicitates several personalities | BJP made people realize meaning of good governance: Kavinder | Thousands of litres of water getting wasted in leak of supply pipe | Despite wet weather, Kashmir highway through for traffic; Mughal road remains shut | Govt constitutes UT & District Level committee for implementation of FPO scheme | DB directs ACB to file ATR with regard to raid on J&K SCARD Bank | Avalanche warning issued for higher reaches in J&K | LG condoles demise of Maulana Kalbe, MP Patel | HC dismisses pre-arrest bail of J&K Bank Employee involved in 37 lakh scam | ACB files chargesheet against then BDO, Storekeeper Barnoti | COVID-19: Govt evacuates 8, 39,170 via Lakhanpur | SSP demands resolve problems of non migrants | Int'l Day for elimination of violence against women | Congress candidate from Bani hits campaign trail, visits village Chandyar | Youth, development of border areas my priority: Satish Sharma | Udhampur Civil Society condoles demise of Pardeep Bakshi's mother | INTACH holds awareness meet at Panjbakhtar Temple | UT Govt should give 50% reservation to Jammu Dogras: Chandel | Special training for phase-I polling staff held at Doda | Shiv Sena extends financial assistance of Rs 4.90 lakhs to needy | Tractor Union resolves to press NOTA button in forthcoming DDC elections | Non-participation in DDC elections would have damaged interests of masses: Tarigami | Webinar on 'Rich Heritage of Jammu' marks 'World Heritage Week' | SKUAST-Jammu convenes academic council meet | 12 tippers seized for illegal transportation of construction material | Govt asks DDOs to ensure contribution towards Armed Forces Flag Day Fund | SI Sumit Mangotra of CBJ shines in debate competition | GDC Chenani organises awareness Program | Mahajan appeals KP migrants to ensure maximum participation in poll process | Open gymnasiums being set up across Srinagar | Sanjeev Kumar files nomination for DDC elections from Sunderbani | Lawyers' agitation for opening of courts, other issues continues | Rapper Shen B's latest single 'Sone Do' rules music charts | DC Udhampur directs eviction of all land encroachments in Patnitop | DDC Kishtwar reviews progress on PMDP, languishing projects | Back Issues  
news details
HC directs GMC Chandigarh to grant admission to petitioner in Common Pool Quota
10/21/2020 12:47:10 AM

JAMMU, Oct 20 : In a petition filed by Taseen Niaz Malik seeking a direction for his admission in MBBS course in Government Medical College, Chandigarh against Central Pool Quota seat allotted to the Union Territory of Jammu and Kashmir.
Justice Rajesh Bindal after hearing Adv Navyug Sethi for the petitioner, observed that in case the candidate is not at fault and had been following his case diligently, he should not be denied admission. The admission can be granted even in next session with a direction to create additional seat.
At the time of hearing it transpired that the Government Medical College, Chandigarh has the sanctioned strength of 150 seats for MBBS. The petitioner is a sufferer of the circumstances, which were beyond his control. He had been nominated for admission for the session commencing in 2019-20, however, could not get admission.
Hence, in my opinion, a direction is required to be issued to the Government Medical College, Chandigarh to grant admission to the petitioner in the session commencing in 2020-21. For the purpose, one additional seat shall be created as no other candidate in any of the category, who is to get admission in the college for the current session should suffer on this account. The college will complete the formalities required for the purpose.
Justice Bindal further observed that as far as the argument raised by learned counsel for the Medical College that this Court does not have the jurisdiction to entertain the lis, suffice to state that it is not a case related to admission in the Government Medical College, Chandigarh only, where the petitioner was to apply and participate in the counseling, which was to take place at Chandigarh.
It is a case in which the petitioner was nominated by BOPEE in J&K for admission against Central Pool Quota seat to the Government Medical College, Chandigarh.
The process of selection for nomination for Central Pool Quota seats was carried out in J&K. After his nomination, the petitioner was just to approach the college for deposit of fee and he was not able to participate in counseling. The cause of action is a bundle of facts and if seen in totality, part of cause of action had arisen in J&K, hence this court has the jurisdiction to entertain the lis.
As far as award of compensation to the petitioner is concerned, in addition to the admission in the current session is concerned, the argument has to be noticed and rejected for the reason that it is not a case in which fault can solely be attributed to the Medical College for denying admission to the petitioner.
It was on account of prevailing circumstances in the Union Territory of J&K (erstwhile State of J&K) that the process of nomination was delayed and thereafter the Medical College had been directed for admission of a student by the Supreme Court.
The action was taken by it considering that one seat was lying vacant. In fact, for filling up that seat, the matter had earlier been taken up with Medical Council of India.
However, as usual no response was given by the authority concerned. It’s nothing else but shirking responsibility. Hence, in my opinion, the petitioner does not deserve to be granted any compensation.
Court further observed that the argument raised by counsel for the respondents that there is no prayer made in the petition for grant of admission for the current session, hence, the writ petition deserves to be dismissed.
The argument does not carry any weight as prayer made in the writ petition is for grant of admission to the petitioner to the first year MBBS course in the 2019-20 session, in view of the selection and recommendations made by the respondent Nos. 2 and 3 under Central Pool Quota allotted to J&K, vide communication dated 27.09.2019. Omnibus prayer is also there in the writ petition.
In any case, the courts can always mould the relief, which a litigant deserves to be granted instead of pushing him to protracted litigation and keeping the matter pending. (JNF)
  Share This News with Your Friends on Social Network  
  Comment on this Story  
Early Times Android App
BSE Sensex
NSE Nifty
Home About Us Top Stories Local News National News Sports News Opinion Editorial ET Cetra Advertise with Us ET E-paper
J&K Govt. Official website
Jammu Kashmir Tourism
Mata Vaishnodevi Shrine Board
Shri Amarnath Ji Shrine Board
Shri Shiv Khori Shrine Board
Train Enquiry
Jammu Kashmir Bank
State Bank of India
Passport Department
Income Tax Department
IT Education
Web Site Design Services
Jammu University
Jammu University Results
Kashmir University
IGNOU Jammu Center