Like our Facebook Page

Early Times Newspaper Jammu, Leading Newspaper Jammu
Breaking News :   Fostering reading habits | Jamaat leader, brothers of terrorists repose faith in democracy | Triumph of democracy: Baramulla breaks 40-yr record of highest turnout | J&K Police Inspector sits over transfer order | Restoration of J&K statehood solemn promise: PM Modi | Injured tourist couple showing improvement | SC refuses to entertain plea against new criminal laws | Cong didn’t revoke Article 370 for appeasement’s sake: Amit Shah | 5 youth detained with fake USD currency notes | 5 youth detained with fake USD currency notes | Weather to remain dry | Fire engulfs forest area in Udhampur | HPLA meeting held at Jaypee University of Information Technology | NC Sunami in Pir Panjal Zone: Rattan Lal Gupta | Tourist arrivals in Kashmir not right barometer of normalcy: Omar Abdullah | Will restore jobs, land rights of J&K taken away by current govt: Azad | CS reviews overall security scenario | Dr Darakhshan Andrabi visits Educational Institutions, meets public delegations, BJP leaders in Poonch | Restoration of Trains | Agniveers are not just soldiers but leaders, innovators, defenders: CDS Anil Chauhan | Delhi HC dismisses plea to mandate doctors specify drugs' side effects to patient | Earthquake of 4 magnitude hits Ladakh | Power shu tdown | Lecture session on "Personal Hygiene" organized | One day teachers training workshop held at GGHSS Bhaderwah | Tawi Trekkers Initiates Summer Reconnaissance Treks | DDC inspects progress of work on Domail-Katra Section of DAK Expressway | Crackdown on illegal mining, 5 vehicles seized | GDC, SHO conduct special lecture on drug abuse, cyber crime at Ghagwal | Cyber Cell solves online financial fraud amounting to Rs 11,12,000 | J&K wins 11 medals in India Skill Competitions 2024 | 5 bovine smugglers arrested, 13 bovines rescued | Police registers 6 FIRs, arrests 5 bovine smugglers, seizes 6 vehicles | Lady murdered, accused husband arrested | DPS Nagbani celebrates 'Atulya Bharat' with a cultural extravaganza | Farewell party at GDC Jourian celebrates final year students | GDC Purmandal organizes an excursion for the students | Sai Shyam College organizes Anti-Tobacco & Anti-Drug awareness program | J&K wins 11 medals in India Skill Competitions 2024 | GDC Nagrota holds elections for the Staff Secretary | SMVDU Alumnus from Institute for Plasma Research, Gujarat interacts with Students | Government Polytechnic College Jammu organizes technical visit to Gladni Grid Station | DPS Kathua hosts Inter-School Zone Level Cricket, Football Tournament | COL Vinod Pmg Jammu discusses post office schemes with Dc Rajouri | PDP hold protest over power crisis Fee hike in Srinagar | Agriculture Department Kashmir celebrates ‘World Bee Day’ | Missing lady along with her minor child traced out within 02 days | BJP all set to create new benchmark in Punjab Lok Sabha Polls: Kavinder | Spl Tribunal dismissed Ex-Deputy CM Wifes’ petition, imposed costs Rs 10 lacs | ECI establishes 187 special polling stations in Baramulla PC: CEO | Back Issues  
news details
Pre-trial injunction against news publication may have severe ramifications for freedom of speech: SC
3/26/2024 10:39:43 PM
NEW DELHI, Mar 26: Courts should not grant ex-parte injunctions against publication of a news article barring in exceptional cases as it may have severe ramifications for the right to freedom of speech of the author and the public's right to know, the Supreme Court has said.
Setting aside a trial court's order directing international media group Bloomberg to take down an allegedly defamatory news article against Zee Entertainment, the top court said injunctions against the publication of material should be granted only after a full fledged trial.
"The grant of a pre-trial injunction against the publication of an article may have severe ramifications on the right to freedom of speech of the author and the public's right to know," a three-judge bench headed by Chief Justice D Y Chandrachud said.
The bench, also comprising Justices Justices J B Pardiwala and Manoj Misra, said an injunction, particularly ex-parte, should not be granted without establishing that the content sought to be restricted is "malicious" or "palpably false".
"Granting interim injunctions, before the trial commences, in a cavalier manner results in the stifling of public debate….In other words, courts should not grant ex-parte injunctions except in exceptional cases where the defence advanced by the respondent would undoubtedly fail at trial," the bench said.
The SC said grant of an interim injunction, before the trial commences, often acts as a "death sentence" to the material sought to be published well before the allegations have been proven.
"While granting ad-interim injunctions in defamation suits, the potential of using prolonged litigation to prevent free speech and public participation must also be kept in mind by courts," it said.
The top court was hearing a plea filed by Bloomberg against the March 14 order of the Delhi High Court, which dismissed its appeal against the trail court order.
The apex court said the error committed by the trial judge had been perpetuated by the high court and the order of the trial judge does not discuss the prima facie strength of the plaintiff's case, nor does it deal with the balance of convenience or the irreparable hardship that is caused.
The trial judge needed to have analysed why such an ex parte injunction was essential, after setting out the factual basis and the contentions of the respondent made before the trial judge, it said.
This being a case of an injunction granted in defamation proceedings against a media platform, the impact of the injunction on the constitutionally protected right of free speech further warranted intervention, the bench added.
"The error committed by the trial judge had been perpetuated by the high court. Merely recording that a prima-facie case exists for a grant of injunction, the balance of convenience lies in Zee's favour and that an irreparable injury would be caused would not amount to application of mind in the case," the bench, also comprising Justices J B Pardiwala and Manoj Misra, said while granting liberty to Zee to approach the trial court afresh with its prayer seeking injunction.
The apex court clarified that the above segment of the judgment and order may not be construed as a comment on the merits of the present case and the purpose of the above segment is to provide the broad parameters to be kept in mind while hearing the application for an interim injunction.
Reacting on the apex court order, Bloomberg News spokesperson had said, "We are very encouraged by today's decision from the Supreme Court of India, and we continue to stand by this story."
  Share This News with Your Friends on Social Network  
  Comment on this Story  
Early Times Android App
BSE Sensex
NSE Nifty
Home About Us Top Stories Local News National News Sports News Opinion Editorial ET Cetra Advertise with Us ET E-paper
J&K Govt. Official website
Jammu Kashmir Tourism
Mata Vaishnodevi Shrine Board
Shri Amarnath Ji Shrine Board
Shri Shiv Khori Shrine Board
Train Enquiry
Jammu Kashmir Bank
State Bank of India
Passport Department
Income Tax Department
IT Education
Web Site Design Services
Jammu University
Jammu University Results
Kashmir University
IGNOU Jammu Center