x

Like our Facebook Page

   
Early Times Newspaper Jammu, Leading Newspaper Jammu
 
Breaking News :   In the Shadows of Raja: “Bou Buttu Bhuta” Redefines Odia Cinema with Spectral Allegory of Rural Struggle | The role of the Anganwadi worker has evolved in tandem | Mental rabies means distance from humans, closeness with dogs | Today, Students must be Empowered to Choose not just what is “Safe,” | Sainik Sahayta Kendra | Under PM Modi’s leadership, J&K emerging as education, innovation hub: LG Sinha | Statehood to J&K: Cong mobilizing support of all 233 opposition Lok Sabha members to mount pressure | Kavinder Gupta assumes charge as Ladakh LG | ‘Want Ladakh to be recognised top tourism destination’ | DGP Prabhat reviews Bhadarwah security | CM Omar interacts with citizens at Raabita office in Srinagar | US designates LeT proxy TRF responsible for Pahalgam attack as terrorist organisation | Fresh batch of over 7,900 pilgrims leaves for holy cave shrine | Ahead of ‘Monsoon Session,’ Rajnath, Shah discuss ‘Operation Sindoor’ with NSA, tri-service chiefs | Truck hits car carrying Amarnath pilgrims, 8 injured | Man killed in Kathua accident | Traffic management committee | ACB arrests JDA official for accepting bribe | IT Deptt enables online utility for ITR-2 filing | CISF achieves record medal haul in 2024-25 | Jammu admin disburses Rs 24. 60 lakh compensation in 1 month | ZPHQ Jammu organises farewell ceremony | Janipur police nabs drug peddler wit 5 grams of heroin substance | Farooq hails Congress for taking up J&K statehood issue | CM Yogi's water conservation drive yields remarkable results in UP | DB upheld acquittal of KZF members | ADGP Armed felicitated DySP (Retd) Surjeet Choudhary | 75th anniversary of NSSO celebrated in Jammu | Dr Andrabi visits Eidgah Srinagar, meets youth delegations | Every disaster a lesson to learn from: CS | Doda police traced out missing lady and re-united with her family | Ramban police organized 'BHAROSA' awareness programmes | Improving infrastructure in lord Krishna's land is priority: Hema Malini | YRS will announce president after 23rd September celebration | APS Akhnoor hosts inspiring felicitation ceremony | Fake social media accounts being used to spark caste tensions, says CM Yogi Adityanath | Kathua police arrests absconder evading arrest | JKAACL organizes plantation campaign | The World Stands with Bharat, A Resounding Blow to Pakistan-Backed Terrorism: Gaurav | CS to kick start Vicharnag Temple renovation work today | NC workers join SBSP | Central University of Jammu organizes "Thursday Mind Meet" | Jammu police gifts selfie point to Akhnoor after national recognition | SKUAST-Jammu organizes ZREAC Kharif meeting | LPU inaugurates Real-World Tech Workplaces at Campus with Capgemini Code Experience Lab | DDC Kathua approves Rs 74.52 Cr District Capex Budget for FY 2025-26 | Bovine smuggling bid foiled by Doda police | First meeting of the 56th IFFI steering committee held in Mumbai | Inter-Nursing College Poster Competition held | Akhnnor Sports Club honours badminton players | India U-31 team wins bronze, U-16 finishes fourth in World Youth Team Bridge Championships | World Women's Chess Cup: All four Indians to play tie-breaks | Jadeja's "incredible fight" at Lord's Test earns him Team India's MVP tag | Free entry for Durand Cup at Jamshedpur | Didn't know that a national women's football team existed when I started out: Aditi Chauhan | Back Issues  
 
news details
Court discharge then ACD Rajouri in alleged illegal appointment case
8/7/2024 10:06:03 PM
Early Times Report
JAMMU, Aug 7: In a set-back to ACB, Special Judge Anticorruption Rajouri-Poonch Mehmood Chowdhary discharged Noor Alam then ACD Rajouri and 72 others in alleged illegal appointment case.
While discharging the alleged accused persons, Special Judge Anticorruption Rajouri-Poonch Mehmood Chowdhary observed that in all the districts of State, the appointment has been made by all the ACD's or other Officers under the circular issued by the Rural Department whereas in many of the districts, similar type of appointments have been made in the department and not followed the above guideline and circular but no such case has been registered against any of the official or officer or Assistant Commissioner Development or against any of the officers of Rural Development Department. The IO concluded in his final report produced before this court that the Government has disengaged all the supported staff who have been appointed illegally without following the circular issued by the Rural Development Department, in all the districts of State. As per the Govt. Order No. 203-RD & PR of 2018 dated 09.08.2018, the Secretary to Government, Department of RD & PR has made an order and disengaged the contractual engagements made under the MGNREGA and in the order, the same is reproduced herein under: "In order to streamline/rationalize the existing contractual engagements made under MGNREGS in accordance with Mahatma Gandhi NREGA guidelines, it is hereby ordered that all the engagements made under the scheme in contravention to rules/norms/guidelines in vogue and without following due procedure shall be discontinued with immediate effect. The Deputy Commissioners shall submit an action taken report in the matter within fifteen days. By order of the Government of Jammu and Kashmir". Sd/- (Sheetal Nanda) IAS Secretary to Government Department of RD & PR.
Court further observed that As per the order issued by the Government, it is clear that in all the districts, the contractual engagements were made in contravention of rules, norms and guidelines and without following the due procedure. In all such engagements, the government has disengaged all the contractual employees.
Court further said that so same is the case in the district Rajouri also and in this district, the contractual engagements which were made without following due procedure has been discontinued. But on the basis of this engagement order made by the Government, instant FIR was registered against the accused no. 1 and investigation has come to the conclusion that accused no. 1 has misused his official position and made the contractual appointments in violation of the Circular and guidelines as prescribed.
Court further observed that it is astonishing that no FIR has been made in any of the districts except the Rajouri and that too only against the accused no. 1 the FIR has been registered for misuse of his official position.
Abuse of the official position: The word official position is severe form of misuse means to use improperly. The word misuse can be expressed as use improperly. The word misuse without criminal intention does not constitute an offence but abuse is misuse with criminal intention or dishonesty. Section 24 of the IPC/RPC defines the word dishonesty.
"Whoever does anything with intention of causing wrongful gain to one person or wrongful loss to another person is said to do that thing dishonestly". The wrongful gain and wrongful loss is defines in Section 23 of RPC. Wrongful gain:- wrongful gain is the gain by unlawful means of property to which the person gaining is not legally entitled. Wrongful loss:- wrongful loss is the loss by unlawful means of property to which the person losing it is legally entitled. Gaining wrongfully or losing wrongfully:- A person is said to be gain wrongfully when such person retains wrongfully, as well as when such person acquires wrongfully. A person is said to lose wrongfully when such person is wrongfully kept out of any property, as well as such person is deprived of property. So in this case there is no wrongful loss caused to the state and also that there is no wrongful gain by the accused no. 1 and all the other accused no. 2 to 73.
Court further observed that this Court is fortified my opinion on the basis of ratio of judgment Krishan Kumar V. Union of India. As per the definitions of wrongfully loss and wrongfully gain, it has come into fore that the action of the accused persons, is amounts to procedural lapse rather than the abuse of process of official position.
Court further observed that in the investigation, the element of illegal gratification has not been established against the accused no. 1. The act of the accused no. 1 engaging the supporting staff in MGNREGA scheme is not in the interest of any individual and it is the interest of the public at large that the supporting staff required to be engaged in the MGNREGA scheme for running in the Rural Development Department. The supporting staff had actually worked in the department and the department has paid remuneration against the work, the alleged accused no. 2 to 73, rendered.
Moreover the accused no. 1 has not engaged the staff against any non existing vacancies, the vacancies were in the department under the scheme and accordingly the engagements were made. When it come into the notice of department that number of such engagements have been made in the department in all the districts of then State of J&K (now U.T.) in violation of circular. The Government has disengaged all such engagements but no such FIR has been registered by the ACB in any of the districts of J&K except Rajouri, Court said.
Court further observed that not a single witness has deposed anything about some illegal or corrupt practice, dishonest intention, demand or acceptance of illegal gratification by the accused no.1. None of the witnesses talks about any conspiracy or payment of any illegal gratification by the accused 2 to 73. The record seized in the case is the personal files and engagement orders of the accused 2 to 73 and the engagement of these accused by the accused no.1 is an admitted fact and not denied by the accused. What has been denied is that there was any such infraction or illegal or corrupt means adopted by the accused no.1 which could attract the provisions of section 5(1)(d) of the PC Act 2006 and I have not found any such evidence on record which could establish that the accused no.1 resorted to corrupt or illegal means or has otherwise abused or misused his official position to obtain for himself or for any other person any valuable thing or pecuniary advantage. There is not a murmur in the statements of all the 29 witnesses about any conspiracy hatched by the accused no.1 with the other accused/beneficiaries to cause any loss to the Govt. Exchequer. The amount which is shown as loss to the State Exchequer i.e. ^-70,77,989/- is admittedly the salary which the accused have received during their engagement for the work done by them and under no circumstances the salary component can be taken a illegal pecuniary benefit as held by Supreme Court and Kerala High Court in the judgments mentioned supra.
So on the basis of discussion, observation and law on the subject, Court is of the considered opinion that there is no material in the charge sheet and also on the statement of witnesses to suggest that the accused no. 1 by entering into conspiracy with the accused no. 2 to 73 awarded undue benefit to them and conferred loss to the state exchequer or accused no. 1 has demanded and accepted any illegal gratification for himself from any of the beneficiaries or person any person related to beneficiary.
The offence under section 5(1) (d) read with 5(2) J&K PC Act Svt.2006 and 120 B RPC prima facie have not been made out against the accused and it is a futile exercise to frame the charges against the accused persons. Moreover, if the charges are to be framed and whatever the evidence has been recorded during investigation if remain unrebuttal in the trial even then there is no scope for conviction under the offence under section 5(1) (d) read with 5(2) J&K PC Act Svt.2006 and 120 B RPC .
In view of the above facts and circumstances, the accused no. 1 to 73 are accordingly discharged from the offences u/s 5(1) (d) read with 5(2) J&K PC Act Svt.2006 and 120 B RPP. Court ordered.
—JNF
  Share This News with Your Friends on Social Network  
  Comment on this Story  
 
 
 
Early Times Android App
STOCK UPDATE
  
BSE Sensex
NSE Nifty
 
CRICKET UPDATE
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
   
Home About Us Top Stories Local News National News Sports News Opinion Editorial ET Cetra Advertise with Us ET E-paper
 
 
J&K RELATED WEBSITES
J&K Govt. Official website
Jammu Kashmir Tourism
JKTDC
Mata Vaishnodevi Shrine Board
Shri Amarnath Ji Shrine Board
Shri Shiv Khori Shrine Board
UTILITY
Train Enquiry
IRCTC
Matavaishnodevi
BSNL
Jammu Kashmir Bank
State Bank of India
PUBLIC INTEREST
Passport Department
Income Tax Department
JK CAMPA
JK GAD
IT Education
Web Site Design Services
EDUCATION
Jammu University
Jammu University Results
JKBOSE
Kashmir University
IGNOU Jammu Center
SMVDU