x

Like our Facebook Page

   
Early Times Newspaper Jammu, Leading Newspaper Jammu
 
Breaking News :   Formulation of PRI, BDC Plan under district Capex Budget 2025-26 discussed | Amarnath Yatra symbol of unity, brotherhood: LG Sinha | Unfazed by terror threats, devotees flock to join Amarnath Yatra | 26,000 pilgrims pay obeisance in 2 days | Pilgrim from UP dies after falling unconscious | Proud to see our daughters breaking barriers, achieving success: LG Sinha | From separatism to mainstream: JeI leader vows to work within constitution | Man conspires with his wife to eliminate her lover | China used India-Pak conflict as 'live lab': Deputy Army Chief | CB presents chargesheet against notorious fraudsters | Govt Employees under UPS to get tax benefit akin to NPS: Finance Ministry | Come and see Kashmir: Shivraj Chouhan to people | Policeman injured in accidental firing | CUET-UG 2025 results announced | Day 3: Search for terrorists continues | New timings announced for courts | Brain Tracks Emotional Transitions Through Music | Disintegration of real life in the reel world, life getting tired in the race of show off | The Digital Revolution: 10 Years of Digital India and Beyond | Tribute To Valor Of Armed Forces | 367 vehicles involved in illegal mining seized by police | Mission YUVA not just an initiative but transformational opportunity: MD & CEO | SSP conducts PCPG meeting at Gandoh | Union Agriculture Secretary visits agricultural institutions, facilities in Kashmir | NFR recognizes track maintainer for timely action in detecting landslide in Lumding-Badarpur hill section | SSP holds crime/security review meeting | Sadhotra seeks strengthening of internet connectivity on Baltal, Pahalgam routes for smooth Amarnath Yatra | Kavinder meets Rajasthan CM in Jaipur; discusses J&K's transformation post Art 370 abrogation | Monsoon Ravages: 43 dead in Himachal Pradesh in 2 weeks, 37 missing | Resolution taken for purity, cleanliness of rivers | HC quashs FIR against then MS SMHS Hospital, Srinagar in corruption case | Naxalism confined to just 5-6 districts now: Rajnath Singh | NIA arrests key absconding accused in murder of Karnataka BJP leader | CJI Gavai assures 'complete transparency' in collegium system | 3-Day Induction Training for newly placed Headmasters of Jammu division concludes | Director Industries visits langar for Amaranth Yatris | Police arrests drug peddler | Despite challenges, mango growers deliver remarkable results using technology: CM Yogi | Drug peddlers nabbed by police, vehicle seized | Missing lady traced within 72 hours by Nowabad police | UP Govt ramps up export focus with third edition of Mega Trade Show | SMVDU NCC Cadets Excel at ATC in Udhampur | DIG Sarah Rizvi felicitates Sunny Mahajan | KSS celebrate Mata Sharika Jyanti with traditional religious fervor | Girdari Lal Dogra Memorial Degree College adopts villages under UBA | DBU celebrates Doctors' Day | GGM Science College unveils admission brochure for 2025-26 | GDC Ramnagar organises summer internship | CUJ approves Research guide ship for constituent colleges, dual degrees in syndicate | Back Issues  
 
news details
Unsuccessful participant cannot turn around, challenge selection process, after participating in it without any challenge: CAT
8/20/2024 10:50:36 PM
Early Times Report
JAMMU, Aug 20: A Bench of Central Administrative Tribunal holds that an unsuccessful participant cannot turn around and challenge the selection process, after participating in it without any challenge.
This significant judgment has been passed by Bench comprising B. Anand (A) Member and Rajinder Singh Dogra (J) Member while hearing a petition seeking quashment of the impugned offer of appointment to the post of teacher group non gazetted dated 23.02.2024 order no A/ 319/2024 EST SEC GZ-SED954.60 and also seeking direction to the respondent to comply with the rule of 2021 issued by the administration of union territory of Ladakh school education department of 2021.
The essence of the conflict involves a notification issued by the National Council for Teachers' Education (NCTE). According to such notification all the applicants or candidates who are B.Ed. degree holders were qualified or acceptable for the post of primary school teachers i.e., for the classes of 1 to 5. Although the Rajasthan Teacher Eligibility Test (RTET) was by the Board of Secondary Education, the State of Rajasthan from the list of eligible applicants or candidates, B.Ed. degree holders were eliminated. This conduct of eliminating candidates or applicants of the Government of Rajasthan was questioned before the High Court of Rajasthan. The High Court of Rajasthan suppressed the notification of the NCTE and held that the B.Ed. degree holder applicants or candidates were restricted and not qualified for the post of primary school teacher.
CAT after hearing both the sides observed that in the present impugned notification they have not cleared whether said post is for primary, or elementary or secondary level and their criteria runs in counter to the said post, as in the said post they have mentioned all together B.Ed along with CIET 1 and CIET 2 for the said which in general cannot read together as if it applies to primary level there is no need of B. Ed (bachelors of education), or if it not for primary there no need of CIET 1 or if it is for elementary or secondary or further, there is need of CIET 2, and there is no requirement of CIET 1 and all cannot be run together for the said post which has not been defined or specified.
Later on, as per direction of this Bench, Tsering Paldan, Director School Education, Ladakh and Delex Nzmsyal, Secretary, Leh autonomous Hill Development Subordinate Service Recruitment Board UT, Ladakh appeared before this Bench in person and submitted the letter dated 24.05.2023 before the Bench in which respondents have clarified that for selection of General Line Teacher, the candidate has to qualify both papers I&II of CIET.
CAT observed that it also appears from the record that many of the applicants had participated in the selection process however, they could not succeed in the same and, thereafter, they have challenged the selection process. CAT held that an unsuccessful participant cannot turn around and challenge the selection process, after participating in it without any challenge.
CAT held that the respondents were well within their right and jurisdiction while seeking the eligibility of passing both the papers CIET I&II for the post of General Line Teacher and CAT found these OA's to be devoid of merit and accordingly both the O.A.'s are dismissed. All the M.A.'s stand disposed of. The interim order stands vacated. Respondents are at liberty to proceed further to complete the process of selection and appointment of the candidates as per advertisement notifications and the scheme of examination.
—JNF
  Share This News with Your Friends on Social Network  
  Comment on this Story  
 
 
 
Early Times Android App
STOCK UPDATE
  
BSE Sensex
NSE Nifty
 
CRICKET UPDATE
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
   
Home About Us Top Stories Local News National News Sports News Opinion Editorial ET Cetra Advertise with Us ET E-paper
 
 
J&K RELATED WEBSITES
J&K Govt. Official website
Jammu Kashmir Tourism
JKTDC
Mata Vaishnodevi Shrine Board
Shri Amarnath Ji Shrine Board
Shri Shiv Khori Shrine Board
UTILITY
Train Enquiry
IRCTC
Matavaishnodevi
BSNL
Jammu Kashmir Bank
State Bank of India
PUBLIC INTEREST
Passport Department
Income Tax Department
JK CAMPA
JK GAD
IT Education
Web Site Design Services
EDUCATION
Jammu University
Jammu University Results
JKBOSE
Kashmir University
IGNOU Jammu Center
SMVDU