x

Like our Facebook Page

   
Early Times Newspaper Jammu, Leading Newspaper Jammu
 
Breaking News :   UNSC report confirms Pak’s role in Pahalgam terror attack | Gandhi Nagar road rage incident: Police arrest accused after 72 hours’ chase | BJP’s central leadership directs J&K unit to launch aggressive campaign on post-370 gains | From ‘Op Mahadev’ to ‘Op Shiv Shakti’: Forces eliminate five terrorists in 72 hours | Lt Col among 2 soldiers die in Leh accident | Bus hits teacher in Kupwara, dies | ‘Attend Independence Day function’ | No Yatra convoy to move from Jammu today | J&K Govt adds new rights in Prison Manual | 2 teachers die after flash floods sweep bike in Batote | Schools shut amid heavy rainfall | Around 489 road projects face delays over land clearance issues: Gadkari | No third-party intervention in Indo-Pak ceasefire: Jaishankar in Rajya Sabha | 2025 Bihar Legislative Assembly Elections | Disturbance in the Seasonal Cycle, a Sign of Crisis | Army’s Pivotal Role | Grand Conclusion of 2nd Taekwondo Championship held | District police Reasi arrests one person with banned Gattu thread in Katra | Jammu Police solves chain snatching case in Chinore | Udhampur Police attaches drug property worth Rs 10 lakhs | Div com Jammu felicitated C3 institute’s students | Mega Blood Donation camp held | CM YUVA scheme turning job seekers into job creators: CM Yogi | Seminar-Cum-Workshop on NEP 2020 held at Gool | DC Poonch reviews implementation of PM Surya Ghar Muft Bijli Yojana | DC Samba reviews preparations for Janmashtami Mela at Narsingh Temple Ghagwal | NFR pays tribute to Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose and His Azad Hind Fauj | Deputy Commissioner Poonch reviews progress of PMGSY projects | GHSS Vijaypur organises FLN-TLM exhibition | KVK Ramban organises INM Training Program for Krishi Udyamis | Massive haul of suspected adulterated Rasgullas seized | Doda Schools promote foundational literacy, numeracy on Day 2 | Satish Sharma launches start-ups at stakeholders meet in SKUAST-K | Digital platforms driving thousands of UP workers towards self-reliance | COAS visits Manipur to review operational preparedness, strengthen military-civil synergy | MLA Javed Hassan Beigh, JKRA president S Surinder Singh Sodhi applaud grand success of 3-day shooting camp in Baramulla | DB partly allows acquittal appeal, awards jail, fine | Cong hands over cheques for education expenses of children | J&K police Kathua destroyed approx 20 quintals narcotics & phychotropic substances | Police initiates poclamation proceedings under 84 BNSS against absconding accused | Altaf Bukhari urges centre to uphold dignity of J&K people | Terror associate held at Nagrota, 3 Pistols, ammunition recovered | BIS JK Branch Laboratory hosts stakeholder consultation seminar with academia and laboratories | 2 thieves arrested by police | MLA Arvind Gupta reviews water supply operations at PHE pumping station | MAM College, organize Inter-college poster making and slogan writing competition | J&K police Kathua destroyed approx 20 quintals narcotics & phychotropic substances | School Education Department grieves loss of three dedicated teachers in Kupwara and Udhampur | Samba police traced out missing person, reunited with family | Government of India dedicated to safeguarding and empowering consumers | IIM Jammu organizes Yoga Session | DC Kulgam flags-off a group of 54 progressive orchardists to SKUAST-K | First Aid Training held | Indian Army conducts three day integrated disaster management symposium | 4 interdistrict narco smugglers arrested; heroin recovered | Shri Amar Kshatriya (Rajput) Sabha holds meeting at Tehsil Jandrah | Asmita Yogasana Championship concludes in Kathua | JKSPYM SLCA organizes one-day awareness program | Missing lady reunited with family by P/S Billawar | Asmita Yogasana Championship concludes in Kathua | Orientation program for first-year students at Sardar Beant Singh State University Gurdaspur | Career Awareness Session organised by Model Academy School | DBU School of Nursing organises alumni meet | GGM Science College organizes Anti-Drug Awareness Programme | GDC Ramnagar organises "Yuva Samvad" under "Viksit Bharat Youth Ambassadors-Yuva Connect Programme" | GDC Ramnagar organizes Awareness Rally on 'Nasha Mukt Bharat' | Back Issues  
 
news details
HC Rejects Charitable Trust's plea for fresh petition in Amarnath langer dispute
6/6/2025 10:26:53 PM
Early Times Report
JAMMU, June 6: Justice Mohd Yousaf Wani of Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh High Court, while rejecting an application seeking withdrawal of a writ petition with liberty to file afresh, held that the jurisdiction exercised under Article 226 of the Constitution is not shackled by procedural technicalities but nor is it an unregulated space for speculative or unjustified litigation maneuvers.
"A writ petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution cannot be allowed to be withdrawn on the basis of any unjustified ground on the pretext that the jurisdiction of the writ Courts is not circumscribed or limited by procedural technicalities, after all there has to be a sound and justified ground for seeking the withdrawal of a writ petition with liberty to file a fresh one on the same subject matter," observed Justice Mohammad Yousuf Wani while dismissing the withdrawal plea filed by Bhole Bhandari Charitable Trust.
The petition was filed by the Trust, seeking judicial direction to the Shri Amarnathji Shrine Board (SASB) to issue an Expression of Interest (EOI) and subsequently a Letter of Intent (LOI) for establishing a bhandara (free langer services) at Panjtharni for the annual Amarnath Yatra, 2025.
The petitioner claimed to have served yatris selflessly for over 28 years and asserted that denial of permission by SASB, despite repeated representations, was arbitrary, non-speaking, and violative of Article 14 of the Constitution.
However, when the matter was partly heard, the petitioner filed an application seeking to withdraw the petition with liberty to file a fresh one. It contended that due to objections raised by SASB's counsel specifically on alleged security concerns there was a necessity to implead the Union of India and UT Governments of Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh as parties, and to amend pleadings comprehensively.
The withdrawal application was strenuously opposed by SASB, represented by Senior Advocate Mr. Mohsin Qadri along with Mr. Anuj Dewan Raina asserted that the withdrawal was neither unconditional nor grounded in law as required under Order XXIII Rule 1 of CPC, and that there was no formal defect in the original writ petition warranting re-litigation.
The respondents further argued that the security concern cited by the petitioner as a new fact was never raised formally by the Board in its pleadings. On the contrary, SASB clarified that the decision to withhold permission for SANJAY 2025 was based on previous violations by the Trust specifically, unauthorized dumping of construction material and operation beyond the closure date during SANJAY 2024.
High Court after examining the petition, withdrawal application, objections, and the rival arguments in full detail, held that the petitioner's grounds for withdrawal with liberty were unjustified and lacking in legal necessity. The Court noted that the principal claim that impleadment of government bodies was essential due to supposed security objections was without basis. The court further stated that the respondents had neither made security the sole or primary ground in their reply, nor had they argued it during hearings in a manner warranting impleadment of new parties.
The Court noted that there was no formal defect in the writ petition as per Order XXIII Rule 1(3) CPC, nor any newly emergent fact that could not be addressed through permissible procedural amendments. Instead, the court held that the request for withdrawal appeared more aimed at taking a second bite at the cherry.
Importantly, the Court made clear that SASB's authority over such matters is exclusive and discretionary. It emphasized that the petitioner Trust had implicitly accepted this, thereby negating the need for further impleadment of government entities. The Court held that issuing invitations for organizing langers during the yatra was a matter of policy and administrative discretion, and not something for judicial micromanagement.
".. It is impliedly accepted by the petitioner trust that issuance of offer/invitation to intending langer organizers for organizing langer during the Annual Shri Amarnathji Yatra is the discretion of the respondents-board. The case in hand is distinguishable from a tender process, in which no qualified and eligible bidder can be stopped from participating in the tender process", Justice Wani pointed.
The court also took exception to the Trust's implied suggestion that the Court must allow withdrawal merely because writ jurisdiction is flexible. "Withdrawal with liberty cannot be granted in the facts and circumstances, where same does not seem to be imperative for elucidation of the real matter in controversy and instead appears to be aimed at giving an extrajudicial colour to the subject matter," the bench underscored.
Stressing that litigation cannot be permitted to evolve into a strategic exercise of trial and error where parties seek repeated opportunities for procedural correction the Court held that even if an application were filed under Order I Rule 10
  Share This News with Your Friends on Social Network  
  Comment on this Story  
 
 
 
Early Times Android App
STOCK UPDATE
  
BSE Sensex
NSE Nifty
 
CRICKET UPDATE
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
   
Home About Us Top Stories Local News National News Sports News Opinion Editorial ET Cetra Advertise with Us ET E-paper
 
 
J&K RELATED WEBSITES
J&K Govt. Official website
Jammu Kashmir Tourism
JKTDC
Mata Vaishnodevi Shrine Board
Shri Amarnath Ji Shrine Board
Shri Shiv Khori Shrine Board
UTILITY
Train Enquiry
IRCTC
Matavaishnodevi
BSNL
Jammu Kashmir Bank
State Bank of India
PUBLIC INTEREST
Passport Department
Income Tax Department
JK CAMPA
JK GAD
IT Education
Web Site Design Services
EDUCATION
Jammu University
Jammu University Results
JKBOSE
Kashmir University
IGNOU Jammu Center
SMVDU