x

Like our Facebook Page

   
Early Times Newspaper Jammu, Leading Newspaper Jammu
 
Breaking News :   PM Modi leads world’s largest ever Yoga gathering of 3 lakh citizens | Continue practising Yoga to be battle-ready: Rajnath Singh urges soldiers | From Siachen to seas, armed forces celebrate ‘big day’ | Yoga reduces stress, enhances quality of life: LG Sinha | Unity in diversity our greatest strength: LG Sinha | India will never restore Indus Water Treaty with Pakistan: Amit Shah | Absconding Head Constable arrested | ACB catches Tehsildar red-handed | 2 months after Pahalgam terror attack: Nation rises above hate, reaffirms unity | Former BDC Member, Ex-Sarpanch nabbed with Heroin | Sharing video footage of polling stations breaches voters’ privacy | Farooq says will move to SC for statehood restoration | Top military brass brief Rajnath Singh on border security, arrangements for Amarnath Yatra | ‘Operation Sindoor told Pak India won’t tolerate terrorism’ | 11th International Yoga Day celebrated at Majestic Bhallesa Gandoh | GDC Marh celebrated Yoga for One Earth, One Health | Rich Harvest School celebrates 11th International Yoga Day | 11th International Yoga Day celebrated at GDC Nagrota | District Police Udhampur celebrated International Yoga Day | Sanjeevani Sharda Kendra Jammu | 11th International Yoga Day Celebrated at Jammu Airport | Uniting Body, Mind and Planet: International Yoga Day 2025 | Music in Education: A Lifeline, not a luxury -On World Music Day | Shiv Shivoham and Yog- “A Path to Embrace Serenity” | Vishwa Yog Sansthan celebrated the International Day of Yoga | Yoga A Key to Health, Harmony, and the Holistic Development of Human Life: Sham Lal Sharma | Satish Sharma attends 11th International Day of Yoga celebration in Jammu | Yoga is India's Soft Power and Global Gift: Devyani Rana | SP Rural Jammu conducts two PCPG meetings | Delegation of CCI president Arun Gupta called upon Chief Minister Omar Abdullah | Jammu Club celebrates International Yoga Day with great enthusiasm | AIIMS Jammu Unites in Spirit and Strength to Celebrate International Yoga Day 2025 | FICCI FLO JKL, Isha Foundation celebrate Int'l Yoga Day | Commissioner Devansh Yadav Leads International Yoga Day celebrations | IIMC, PIB organise yoga sessions on the occasion of International Day of Yoga 2025 | Iran's gesture a testament to India's growing Global respect under PM Modi: Kavinder | CGPWA, PNB, morning walkers jointly celebrate Yoga Day | PTTI Vijaypur organizes International Yoga Day | District police Udhampur seized 2 vehicles | International Yoga Day celebrated at Directorate of Health Services Jammu | DC Reasi finalises arrangements for annual Kousar Nag Yatra | SCCU organized Yoga camp for senior Citizens | Bovine smuggling bid foiled by Doda police | IIM Jammu celebrates 11th International Day of Yoga | KC College of Education celebrated International Yoga Day | GDC RS Pura organizes Yoga Session on International Day of Yoga 2025 | GDC Neeli Nallah Udhampur celebrates International Yoga Day | Demonstration of Yoga on International Yoga Day at GDC Majalta | Unique International Public School celebrates International Yoga Day | GDC Katra celebrates International Yoga Day | Govt Degree College Ramgarh celebrates 11th International Day of Yoga | GDC Vijaypur celebrates International Yoga Day | GDC Ramnagar celebrates International Yoga Day | GDC Darhal celebrates International Yoga Day | GDC Thannamandi hosts Weeklong Workshop to celebrate International Day of Yoga | Back Issues  
 
news details
Model law on prisons doesn’t have reference of caste-based discriminations: SC
10/3/2024 10:58:13 PM
NEW DELHI, Oct 3:
Agencies

The Supreme Court on Thursday said the provisions of Centre’s ‘Model Prisons and Correctional Services Act’ of 2023 do not contain a reference to the prohibition of caste-based discrimination in jails.
The observation to this effect was made by a bench comprising Chief Justice D Y Chandrachud and Justices J B Pardiwala and Manoj Misra in a landmark judgement by which it banned banned caste-based discrimination like division of manual labour, segregation of barracks and bias against prisoners of denotified tribes and habitual offenders.
The Union Ministry of Home Affairs, in consultation with various stakeholders, had prepared a draft legislation to replace previous “colonial legislations” which were “found to be outdated and obsolete”.
The MHA told the bench that the Model Act was “a comprehensive document which covers all relevant aspects of prison management, viz. security, safety, scientific & technological interventions, segregation of prisoners, special provision for women inmates, taking appropriate action against criminal activities of prisoners in the prison, grant of parole and furlough to prisoners, their education, vocational training and skill development, etc.”
The CJI, in his judgement, said, “the Model Act does not contain a reference to the prohibition of caste-based discrimination. This is concerning because the Act empowers the officer-in-charge of the prison to ‘utilize the services of prisoners’ for ‘administration and management of the prisons’”.
While the Model Prison Manual of 2016 refers to the prohibition of caste discrimination in prisons in several provisions, the Model Act of 2023 has “completely avoided any such mention”, the judgement said.
It also found fault with the definition of “Habitual Offender” under the 2023 law and termed it “problematic”.
It states that, ‘Habitual Offender means a prisoner who is committed to prison repeatedly for a crime’. The phrase ‘committed to prison repeatedly’ is vague and over-broad.
“It can be used to declare anyone as a habitual offender, even if they have not been convicted for a crime,” the judgement said.
The top court also analysed the manuals and the rules by examining whether caste was a ground of classification before the Constitution came into force and referred to historical instances.
“According to the Committee on Prison Discipline 1836-38, to force a man of ‘higher caste’ to work at any trade would ‘disgrace him’ and his family, and would be viewed as cruelty,” it said.
“However, this Court cannot adopt the approach taken by the colonial administrators. The impugned provisions shall be examined on the basis of principles
The top court also analysed the manuals and the rules by examining whether caste was a ground of classification before the Constitution came into force and referred to historical instances.
aid under the Constitution,” it said.
It also said caste can be an intelligible principle of classification as it has been used to create protective policies for the marginalized castes.
The Constitution recognises caste as a proscribed ground of discrimination under Article 15(1) and envisions a society free from caste-prejudices, it said.
“However, as evident from the language of Article 15(1), caste cannot be a ground to discriminate against members of marginalized castes. Any use of caste as a basis for classification must withstand judicial scrutiny to ensure it does not perpetuate discrimination against the oppressed castes.
“While caste-based classifications are permissible under certain constitutional provisions, they are strictly regulated to ensure they serve the purpose of promoting equality and social justice,” it said.
In the context of prisons, valid classification must be a functional classification and it should be done keeping in mind the security, discipline as well as reform and rehabilitation.
“This has been the objective. However, there is no nexus between classifying prisoners based on caste and securing the objectives of security or reform. Limitations on inmates that are cruel, or irrelevant to rehabilitation are per se unreasonable, arbitrary and constitutionally suspect,” it said.
Inmates are entitled to fair treatment that promotes rehabilitation and classification of any kind must be geared towards the same, it said.
“Courts have been enjoined with the duty ‘to invigorate the intra-mural man-management so that the citizen inside has spacious opportunity to unfold his potential without overmuch inhibition or sadistic overseeing’,” it said.
Segregating prisoners on the basis of caste would reinforce caste differences or animosity that ought to be prevented at the first place and it would not lead to rehabilitation, it added.
“We have held that assigning cleaning and sweeping work to marginalised and assigning cooking to higher caste is nothing but violation of Article 15 (it forbids discrimination on grounds of religion, race, caste, gender, or place of birth or any of them),” the CJI said.
The bench referred to an Uttar Pradesh law which provides that a person undergoing simple imprisonment will not work in degrading and menial work unless his caste is used to do such jobs.
“We hold that no group is born as a scavenger class or to do or not do menial jobs. The classes who can cook and who cannot cook are aspects of untouchability which cannot be permitted….Sweepers should be chosen from ‘chandal’ caste is nothing but entirely opposed to substantive equality and a facet of institutional discrimination.”
  Share This News with Your Friends on Social Network  
  Comment on this Story  
 
 
 
Early Times Android App
STOCK UPDATE
  
BSE Sensex
NSE Nifty
 
CRICKET UPDATE
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
   
Home About Us Top Stories Local News National News Sports News Opinion Editorial ET Cetra Advertise with Us ET E-paper
 
 
J&K RELATED WEBSITES
J&K Govt. Official website
Jammu Kashmir Tourism
JKTDC
Mata Vaishnodevi Shrine Board
Shri Amarnath Ji Shrine Board
Shri Shiv Khori Shrine Board
UTILITY
Train Enquiry
IRCTC
Matavaishnodevi
BSNL
Jammu Kashmir Bank
State Bank of India
PUBLIC INTEREST
Passport Department
Income Tax Department
JK CAMPA
JK GAD
IT Education
Web Site Design Services
EDUCATION
Jammu University
Jammu University Results
JKBOSE
Kashmir University
IGNOU Jammu Center
SMVDU