x

Like our Facebook Page

   
Early Times Newspaper Jammu, Leading Newspaper Jammu
 
Breaking News :   Significance of Kartik Purnima | Anant Ambani’s compassion revolution: From Vantara to a new era of animal care | The Sacred Bond of Tulsi Vivah On Davuthani / Haribodhini Ekadashi | Article 370 abrogation ended separatist sentiments among Kashmir youth: Amit Shah | Engage in governance, nation-building: CM Omar to youth | DGP Prabhat reviews ongoing security operations in Jammu zone | Defying boycott call, braving sub-zero cold, Ladakh records nearly 65% turnout in Panchayat polls | India has shown it can break limits, unlock possibilities: PM Modi | HC orders judicial reshuffle, transfers 7 civil judges; Additional charge of 4 courts reassigned | Vaishno Devi footfall reaches 87 lakh | Man climbs mobile tower over alleged land records dispute | NCB uncovers inter-state drug trafficking network in J&K, 4 held | Soldier found dead | Mercury stays above normal in J&K | Pak national arrested near IB | Rs 1-cr property of drug peddler attached | DIET Jammu concludes three-day capacity building programme | Jatt Sabha flags fertilizer shortage, Kisan ID hurdles before Jammu Div Com, Director Agriculture | Haryana's largest modern rest house to be built in Kurukshetra at a cost of Rs 120 Crore: CM | SMVDNSH, ACCLMP jointly organize pre-conference national CME on advances in laboratory medicine | A sporting excellence celebrated at APS Damana | Two-day training under 'Poshan Bhi Padhai Bhi' concludes in Udhampur | Awantipora police apprehends two more drug peddlers in backward linkage of NDPS case | Indian Army organised awareness lecture | Eminent artist KK Gandhi invited to participate in State Gallery of Art | IGP Traffic J&K inspected arrangements for Baba Jatoo Mela, congestion points, ongoing construction works in Jammu City | PDP chief Mufti demands halt of upcoming JKSSB exams over malpractice allegations | MVD Rajouri conducts 2-day enforcement drive; Rs 3.92 lakh fine imposed, 5 vehicles seized | President of India Droupadi Murmu to review Passing Out Parade of autumn term 2026 | Chief Secretary Dr Sajjan Singh undertakes first district visit to Reasi | TR Gupta Trust holds awareness lecture on spinal disorders | BJP betraying people of J&K by denying them their constitutional rights, restore statehood without further delay: Sadhotra | Sr vice president Anil Gupta JCCI urges Govt to focus on revival of existing industries in new industrial policy | Rape chargesheet cannot be quashed on victim's retraction: HC | Samba police arrests one more absconder, executes arrest warrant under section 512 CrPC | BSF school staff can't claim pay parity through writ: HC | Women must take leadership roles in politics, Nation-Building: Governor Kavinder Gupta | PM Modi dedicated second unit of SJVN's 1320 MW Buxar Thermal Power Project in Bihar to the Nation | Back Issues  
 
news details
Non-judicial members of tribunals averse to passing orders against Govt: CJI
9/20/2025 10:17:24 PM
New Delhi, Sept 20:

Chief Justice of India (CJI) B R Gavai on Saturday said some of the non-judicial members of the tribunals, who are usually ex-bureaucrats, are averse to passing any orders against the government and urged them to reflect.
Addressing the 10th All India Conference of the Central Administrative Tribunal 2025 here, the CJI flagged various issues plaguing the tribunals and the country’s justice delivery system in the presence of Union Law Minister Arjun Ram Meghwal and Union Minister of State in the Prime Minister’s Office Jitendra Singh.
CJI Gavai said the administrative tribunals are unlike courts as they occupy a unique space between the executive and the judiciary, and many of their members come from administrative services while others come from the judiciary.
Though this diversity presents a strength as it brings together judicial acumen and administrative experience, it makes it imperative that members are consistently trained and held to uniform standards of eligibility and conduct, he said.
“Judicial members would benefit from exposure to the nuances of public administration, while administrative members would require training in legal reasoning. I should not be taken otherwise because nowadays you don’t know what you say and what comes on social media.
“But as a judge, I have personally noticed that some of the administrative members — some of the judges coming from the administration… do not forget that they come from the administration and… are averse to passing any order which will be against the government. So I think they should reflect on that…,” the CJI said.
He added that regular workshops, conferences and training programmes conducted by judicial academicians can prove invaluable in this regard and greatly enhance the effectiveness of the tribunal members.
“Furthermore, if a uniform appointment process is enacted with clear eligibility criteria, this would abate all questions of arbitrariness and reinforce the trust of the citizens in the tribunal,” CJI Gavai said.
He also flagged the multiplicity of appeals which arises from the tribunals’ decisions, an issue that was also highlighted by Meghwal in his address, in cases where there are concurrent findings of the Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT) and high courts but still appeals are filed in the apex court.
This happens because bureaucrats are afraid of taking any risk and want to pass on the buck to the courts, he said.
“If you can have some central agency to filter as to whether the matter really deserves to be appealed or not, that will greatly reduce the pendency of the matters before the court. All of us know that the central government is the biggest litigant before the Supreme Court, as well as the high courts,” he added.
The CJI said that though the citizens’ right to appeal is the cornerstone of justice, this process often results in lengthy litigation spanning years, therefore undermining the purpose of establishing tribunals.
In numerous instances, he said, the government officials and officers reach the age of retirement before their cases are finally resolved.
CJI Gavai further flagged the issue of uniform service conditions for members of tribunals and said the government needs to address this issue urgently.
“If the government desires that the retired judges of the high court and good judicial officers should adorn the offices of the tribunals, a quick look, or a quick relook at the service conditions of the chairperson and the members of the tribunals is I think the need of the day,” he said.
The CJI was also critical of the conduct of some judges and judicial officers in courtrooms and referred to a recent decision of the apex court where it made it mandatory for a fresh law graduate to have an experience of three years before appearing in the judicial service examination.
He said that data was sought from the states and the high courts, and it was found that the fresh law graduates, who did not have any experience, or exposure of the court, “the chair would go to their head on the very first day, and they would browbeat or irritate the lawyers with a standing of 40 years and 50 years”.
Referring to a recent incident where a young lawyer fell unconscious in a high court after being browbeaten by a judge, he said, “As judges, we must also accept the position that both judges, as well as the lawyers, are like two wheels of the golden chariot of justice. None superior or none inferior, unless both the judges and the lawyers work together, the institution of administration of justice, which exists for the last citizen of this country, cannot function properly.” He said all litigants who appear before the court do so with the faith that they will receive justice and their judgements will not be coloured.
“I urge everyone to honour this responsibility not just within the official spaces but outside as well. In many ways, our roles are like those of a leader who will shape the lives of several thousand citizens through the outcomes that we determine…,” CJI Gavai said.
He lauded the contribution of CAT and state tribunals in the justice delivery system.
Attorney General R Venkatramani also spoke on the occasion and highlighted that the tribunals help in reducing the pendency of litigation. (PTI)
  Share This News with Your Friends on Social Network  
  Comment on this Story  
 
 
 
Early Times Android App
STOCK UPDATE
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
   
Home About Us Top Stories Local News National News Sports News Opinion Editorial ET Cetra Advertise with Us ET E-paper
 
 
J&K RELATED WEBSITES
J&K Govt. Official website
Jammu Kashmir Tourism
JKTDC
Mata Vaishnodevi Shrine Board
Shri Amarnath Ji Shrine Board
Shri Shiv Khori Shrine Board
UTILITY
Train Enquiry
IRCTC
Matavaishnodevi
BSNL
Jammu Kashmir Bank
State Bank of India
PUBLIC INTEREST
Passport Department
Income Tax Department
JK CAMPA
JK GAD
IT Education
Web Site Design Services
EDUCATION
Jammu University
Jammu University Results
JKBOSE
Kashmir University
IGNOU Jammu Center
SMVDU