x

Like our Facebook Page

   
Early Times Newspaper Jammu, Leading Newspaper Jammu
 
Breaking News :   Terrorist country Pak wants to derail J&K’s development journey: LG Sinha | LG visits Nunwan base camp, interacts with pilgrims, officials, others | RSS to reach every home during centenary year | Op Sindoor led to increase in demand for indigenous defence products: Rajnath Singh | Army, Defence Minister pay tribute to Capt Batra | Azad unofficially disbands DPAP as key leaders desert party! | Pahalgam terror attack: NIA gets custody of 2 accused for 10 more days | Day 5: 23,857 pilgrims pay obeisance, figure crosses 90,000 mark | 3 yatris among 4 injured in Anantnag accident | Court rejects bail of woman involved in terror activities | BSF jawan shoots himself dead | 2 civilians stranded on landslide-hit road rescued | Kashmir: Schools to reopen today | Mission Director HADP inaugurates capacity building programme of FPO’s | Conduct of Medical Patrol for Awam at Songri, Rajouri | Ex-Servicemen Rally, outreach Program conducted | Shri Amar Kshatriya Rajput Sabha holds meeting | Awareness Camp organized under Dharti Aaba Janjatiya Utkarsh Abhiyan | Take Modi government’s 11 years of achievements to every household: Balbir | Empowering Voices of Justice: National Gurjar Advocates Conference held | Two-day Shoulder Rehabilitation workshop organises | DLSA Srinagar organizes awareness programme on drug abuse | Amarnath Yatra a spiritual & religious journey | Invisible Walls | Parched Paradise: Scorching heat dries up Kashmir’s Summer Charm | LG Sinha’s Rallying Call | BNI J&K hosts 4th edition, uniting 300 business leaders from across India, honoring top | One notorious drug peddler nabbed by Jammu Police | Himachal Rains: Rescue Operations On To Trace 30 Missing After Cloudbursts, Landslips In Mandi | Police arrests a drug peddler from Bus Stand | BRO CE calls on Dy CM; discusses road infra in Jammu province | Adityanath pays tributes to Kargil martyr Captain Vikram Batra on death anniversary | Delhi Speaker meets Amit Shah, briefs about ongoing initiatives in Assembly | Youtuber Jyoti Malhotra's Judicial Custody Extended By 14 Days In Espionage Case | ISRO Chief Dr V Narayanan meets CM Yogi, explores dedicated satellite for Uttar Pradesh | 'Approval for Phase IV of the Pradhan Mantri Gram Sadak Yojana will be given as per the state's proposal' - Shri Shivraj Singh | NFR Strengthens Safety Measures for Monsoon Operations | DIG JKS Range Shiv Kumar IPS conduct Security Review | HC dismissed petition with costs Rs 50000 | Elderly man loses Rs 73.72 lakh in gold trading draud after meeting woman on dating app | Luggage packed, will move out of official residence: Ex-CJI DY Chandrachud | Van Mahotsav 2025: Forest Dept to plant 3.5 crore saplings along riverbanks | Shrine Board Judokas to represent India at International Competitions | International recognition of cross-border terrorism validates India's stand: Kavinder Gupta | DC Kulgam takes review of Mission YUVA; assesses implementation, progress | Sheep Husbandry deptt organizes PMFME workshop/awareness programme | ABRSM delegation meets CEO Jammu, highlights teachers' key issues | Macadamization work begins on Tujjar Sharief to Zaingeer road, Baramulla | Over Rs.41 crore allocated under DDC, BDC, PRI & Aspirational Grants in Bandipora | PAC holds meet at Srinagar, discusses Audit Paras of HUDD | J&K Cine Association slams 'Hillywood' label as misleading and politically driven | UP CM orders strict action against those attempting to defile Kanwar Yatra | 5 of family murdered on suspicion of practising witchcraft in Bihar, oppn slams govt | PM Modi at BRICS, a global wake-up call against terrorism: Gaurav Gupta | Shiv Sena distributed poster to Amarnath pilgrims for 'Jammu-Darshan' | SBI hands over Rs 1.10 Crore DSP PAI claim to family of Martyr Rifleman Sunil Kumar | Mission Director HADP inaugurates five-day Capacity Building Programme for FPOs | Beating the heat wave and humidity, IGNOU flying squad teams charge into Exam Centres for on-the-spot monitoring | FVSc and AH, SKUAST-Jammu celebrates World Zoonoses Day- 2025 | Annual congregation of All India Rohmetra Mahajan Biradari on 10th , July | Bovine smuggling attempt foiled, 09 bovines rescued, in Latti | LIC of India introduces new Plans LIC's Nav Jeevan Shree (Plan 912) & LIC's Nav Jeevan Shree Single Premium (Plan 911) | 15-day Youth Development Programme on 'Premier Banker' inaugurates | Mechanical Engineering students of DBU developed "Multi-Utility Power Generating Kit" | 'Kala aur Atmanirbharta' culminates at MCM | Tanvi Sharma eyes junior titles before full-fledged senior switch | JKCCA appoints Dr Rekha Rani Sharma as Advisor | Pinegrove Director elected president BSAI | Aryaveer and Aaryavir: The Kohli, Sehwag connection at this year's DPL | Indian archers eye World Championship preparation at Madrid World Cup | Back Issues  
 
news details
Government servant cannot be discharged from service only on account of the pendency of a criminal case against him: CAT
6/21/2024 10:05:59 PM
Early Times Report
JAMMU, June 21: Central Administrative Tribunal holds that the service of a Government servant cannot be terminated or the Government servant cannot be discharged from service only on account of the pendency of a criminal case against him. The reason is obvious. Unless the guilt is proved, one is presumed to be innocent. Moreover, criminal case may be launched out of enmity etc. It is, therefore, the conviction and not the pendency of a criminal case which should be taken into account for disciplinary action."
This significant judgment has been passed by a Bench of Central Administrative Tribunal comprising B Anand Member (A) and Rajinder Singh Dogra Member (J) in a petition filed by Arsam Imtyaz Malik seeking setting aside Order No.CEJ/ADM/01 of 2024 dated 03-012024 issued by the respondent No.2 by virtue of which the appointment order issued in favour of the applicant under SRO 43 has been withdrawn that too without adhering to the principles of natural justice and also seeking direction to the respondents to allow the applicant to perform his duties at PWD (R&B) Division Bhaderwah pursuant to his appointment order dated 05-12-2023 and joining order dated 06-12- 2023."
The applicant is aggrieved of the Govt. Order No.CEJ/ADM/01 of 2024 dated 03-01-2024 issued by the respondent No.2 by virtue of which the appointment order issued in favour of the applicant under SRO 43 has been withdrawn that too without adhering to the principles of natural justice. The applicant came to be appointed under SRO 43 on account of death of his father by virtue of Order No.CEJ/ADM/232 of 2023 dated 22-11-2023 issued by the respondent No.2 in compliance to the approval conveyed by the administrative department. Pursuant to his appointment, the applicant came to be posted in PWD (R&B) Division, Bhaderwah for further duties by the respondent No.3 by virtue of Order No.CEC/Adm/05 of 2023 dated 05-12-2023 and accordingly the applicant joined in PWD (R&B) Division Bhaderwah on 06-122023.
The applicant at the time his appointment was made to swear an affidavit in which the applicant has sworn that he has not been convicted in any offence by any court of law and the applicant is facing trial in one case. It is only after swearing the aforementioned affidavit that the applicant was allowed to join and came to be posted in PWD (R&B) Division, Bhaderwah. On 23.12.2023, the respondent No. 4 addressed a communication bearing No. EE /PWD /R&B /BHD /2023-24/1055-56/8 in which it has been averred that the applicant has been allowed to join in the division after proper verification of the documents and on the receipt of character/antecedent certificate from CID issued by the SSP/Dy SP Headquarters for Special DG CID J&K vide Form No.55821 dated 17-05-2023 on 06-12-2023. It has further been averred that the affidavit sworn by the applicant reveals that he is under trail in one case and the said case is not disposed till date and accordingly the instructions were sought for the withdrawal of the salary of the applicant by the respondent No.4 from the respondent No.3.
CAT after hearing Adv Sheikh Najeeb for the applicant whereas Deputy AG Hunar Gupta for the UT, observed that the Rule(s) as mentioned hereinabove, nowhere provide pendency of a criminal case against a candidate to disqualify him for his entry into the service. The reason for this is obvious. Pendency of a criminal case cannot lead to the conclusion of committing the offence by the accused. Presumption is otherwise. No person is presumed to be guilty of an offence unless convicted by a competent Court after trial. It is also our common experience that trial of a criminal case consumes much time and ultimately the accused may be acquitted therein. Refusal of appointment on the ground of pendency of a criminal case would, therefore, result in miscarriage of justice to the candidate because even on his ultimate acquittal he cannot enter into service, CAT said.
CAT further observed that adverting to the facts of the instant case, it would be noticed that the applicant himself by virtue of an affidavit has disclosed the fact that an FIR has been registered against him bearing No.0087/2023 under Section 8/21 of NDPS Act of Police Station, Bhaderwah which is pending disposal in the court of Sub Judge, Bhaderwah.
CAT is of the considered view that mere registration of an FIR cannot be made the basis and equated with a finding of guilt recorded by a competent Court. In other words, registration of a case cannot lend the colour of conviction. The action of the respondent department in terminating the applicant would amount to holding the applicant guilty of the offence. Such a course of action would be totally unwarranted.
CAT held that the service of a Government servant cannot be terminated or the Government servant cannot be discharged from service only on account of the pendency of a criminal case against him. The reason is obvious. Unless the guilt is proved, one is presumed to be innocent. Moreover, criminal cases may be launched out of enmity etc. It is, therefore, the conviction and not the pendency of a criminal case which should be taken into account for disciplinary action."
In the facts and circumstances of the case, CAT is of the considered view that the respondents could not have straightway terminated the applicant without considering the relevant factors like the nature and gravity of the accusation because, in case, these allegations are subsequently found to be false or not proved in the trial, resulting in acquittal, the same would cause undue hardship to the applicant, as the applicant would then be appointed only after getting clearance during investigation and trial and would be offered appointment subsequently occurring vacancies for no fault on his part, which may take several years if not decades.
CAT further observed that as stated earlier, the applicant has not been terminated on the ground that his character is such which makes him unsuitable for the service. Neither it is the case of the respondents nor there is any adverse report against the applicant of this nature after verification of his antecedents. Hence, CAT is of the definite view that the applicant has wrongly been terminated merely on the ground of pendency of FIR against him.
Termination here is in violation of principles of natural justice as before resorting to termination a reasonable opportunity to show cause had not been accorded to the applicant. Natural justice is implicit in rules and has to be read as part and parcel thereof, if not specifically provided, as held by the Apex Court in J.A. Naiksatam v. Prothonotary Senior Master.
With these observations CAT allowed the petition and impugned Order No.CEJ/ADM/01 of 2024 dated 03-01-2024 issued by the respondent No.2 by virtue of which the appointment order issued in favour of the applicant under SRO 43 has been withdrawn, is hereby set aside. Respondents are directed to allow the applicant to perform his duties at PWD (R&B) Division Bhaderwah pursuant to his appointment order dated 05.12.2023 and joining order dated 06.12.2023.
CAT further said that on conclusion of the criminal trial, law shall take its own course, and the appointment offered to the applicant may be withdrawn / terminated. —JNF
  Share This News with Your Friends on Social Network  
  Comment on this Story  
 
 
 
Early Times Android App
STOCK UPDATE
  
BSE Sensex
NSE Nifty
 
CRICKET UPDATE
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
   
Home About Us Top Stories Local News National News Sports News Opinion Editorial ET Cetra Advertise with Us ET E-paper
 
 
J&K RELATED WEBSITES
J&K Govt. Official website
Jammu Kashmir Tourism
JKTDC
Mata Vaishnodevi Shrine Board
Shri Amarnath Ji Shrine Board
Shri Shiv Khori Shrine Board
UTILITY
Train Enquiry
IRCTC
Matavaishnodevi
BSNL
Jammu Kashmir Bank
State Bank of India
PUBLIC INTEREST
Passport Department
Income Tax Department
JK CAMPA
JK GAD
IT Education
Web Site Design Services
EDUCATION
Jammu University
Jammu University Results
JKBOSE
Kashmir University
IGNOU Jammu Center
SMVDU