Like our Facebook Page

Early Times Newspaper Jammu, Leading Newspaper Jammu
Breaking News :   Cabinet approves changes to abortion bill raising upper limit to 24 weeks | Srinagar to Jammu highway remain closed, hundreds of vehicle stranded | India launches Operation Vanilla to help cyclone, flood-ravaged Madagascar | Nirbhaya case: SC dismisses convict Mukesh's plea against no mercy petition by President | Jaws of death shatter Khan Family’s dream of purchasing fresh blankets for flooring | No compensation for victims of ‘mysterious disease’ in Udhampur | Deputed for campaign in Delhi, J&K BJP leaders busy in photo sessions | What next? Holiday cancelled, police medals rechristened | SSA funds worth lakhs meant for construction of toilet complexes in schools embezzled | J & K crown of India; It is our responsibility to pull it out of its turmoil: PM | ZEO Sathara comes forward to support truant teachers | Agents rule the roost in Govt.’s hospitals | Despite drawing HRA, GMC Anantnag faculty members leave Hospital everyday | Earned international accolade for State in Karate, Rajouri girl’s achievements remain unrecognised | SDRF aspirants hold protest | Ministers came, left without meeting people : Bhardwaj | Red Ribbon Club organizes ‘Positive Talk’ | Div Com reviews utilization plan for vacant school buildings | Govt mulling ‘School Nutrition Gardens’ in all J&K Schools: Dr Manhas | Roller skating players felicitated | Chief Secretary reviews arrangements for Shri Amarnathji Yatra-2020 | J&K ICAI organizes seminar, demands extension for filing GSTR 9 & 9C in J & K | IMA celebrates Annual Sports Day | JSS outshines in Taekwondo National Championship | DPS excels in American Mathematics Competition-8 | Govt to organise road shows next week to pull investors in JK | LeT militant arrested in Pattan area, unidentified gunmen lobbed grenade in Tujjer | Joginder Pal Singh Congress MLA from Punjab held hostage JK officials | Weather in J&K likely to remain wet till January 29, Jammu-Srinagar Highway closed | Stormwater drainage to be major developmental focus in Srinagar in coming fiscal | Traffic suspended on Jmu-Sgr NH due to fresh snowfall | Northern Army Commander meets Lt Governor | Coronavirus epidemic: Govt orders screening of people arriving at airports | Association announces probable for 46th Junior National Kabaddi Championship | Situation in J-K along LoC, in hinterland under control: Lt Gen Saini | Gandhinagar Morning Walkers celebrates R-Day | Former Minister Bukhari denies forming new political party | Chhattisgarh score 270/4, rains spoils day 2 | BJP Govt failed to address genuine issues of Jammu people: Bhalla | Several students from MAM College join AAP | Chairman PCB inaugurates sanitary waste disposer unit at GCW Gandhi Nagar | NHM employees’ delegation meets Advisor Bhatnagar | Training programme on General Provident Fund Rules concludes | LMD conducts market checking at Kishtwar | DIC organises awareness camp | Randhir congratulates Baig for Padma Bhushan award | Trust to hold Multispecial Medical Camp at village Rehal | Compensate fruit growers adequately who suffered losses due to snowfall: Monga to govt | SKUAST witness live video telecast of “Global Potato Conclave” | AM Tata launches New Premium Hatch Altroz | KKHMS urges Govt to redress grievances of Kashmiri migrants | Swami Vishwatamanand Saraswati Maharaj’s birth anniversary observed | Dir Information advises students to work hard for achieving their goals | IGP Jammu issues formal promotion order | Induction Programme for student Excellence, learning starts at GGM Science College | BSF to be armed with anti-drone system at International Border soon | Ease of doing business: 149 of 187 reforms proposed by Centre implemented in JK | Check menace of quacks, spurious drugs in Ramnagar: Harsh Dev | VDC members threaten to surrender weapons over pending salaries | Congress leader conducts door to door campaign in old city | Delegation of JKESTEWS meets Advisor | Court takes serious note for not filing report in Kishtwar militancy case, directs IG for enquiry | Vaishno Devi Board introduces screening of live ‘Atka Aarti’ for pilgrims | Power shut down | Court rejects bail plea of job scam accused | Filth, garbage scattered near PHE water tank at Mendhar | DySP Surankote Javaid Tabassum seizes four tippers involving in illegal mining | BGSBU approach road in dilapidated condition, commuters aghast | HC asks govt not to allow encroachments on Jhelum River | Dachal villages without water | DDC reviews bottlenecks impending NH-44 four laning project, resolves confronting issues | Militant killed, jawan injured | Three sentenced for attempt to outrage modesty of girl | Absconder arrested in Thanamandi | Shan demands inspection by NHPC, Power Ministry to Pakul Dul Power Project | DC reviews functioning of Revenue department | DLTFC approves 46 cases under PMEGP at Kishtwar | LMD conducts market checking at Kishtwar | Councillor honored for better work | Chinese anti-India diplomatic manoeuvres at behest of Pakistan | Krishi Vigyan Kendras (KVKs) - Tools for Rural Transformation | On respecting our National Flag | Jammu is not Kashmir | Back Issues  
news details
Ujjawala Yojna - oil companies benefitted more than those deserve
Jamwal Mahadeep Singh8/8/2018 10:51:53 PM
Welfare schemes for vulnerable sections of the population loaded with vote bank politics always carry fewer merits and more demerits and the Pradhan Mantri Ujjwala Yojana to improve the life of women hailing from BPL household's well suits in this frame. We must accept finite disappointment, but never lose infinite hope - Martin Luther King, Jr. One should have a big enough heart to unconditionally accept follies, and a broad enough mind to embrace the goodies that may come from even the worst critics. But in actuality, we (especially politicians) never bow before the facts that good ideas when implemented on ground, without exploring pros and cons, the negativity thereof, we always suppress and keep our lies atop for self aggrandizement. Same is the case with much hyped 'Pradhan Mantri Ujjawala Yojna (PMUY)' a laudable but lacking certain requirement at the implementation level. The government launched the scheme in haste. The fact that the scheme would not meet its objectives would have been obvious to the government if it only it had waited for the results of a study it commissioned from the rating and analytics company CRISIL in 2015 to try to understand why users were not abandoning biomass fuels for cleaner LPG cylinders. Between October and December 2015, CRISIL surveyed more than one lakh people without gas connections across 120 districts in 13 states. The results were submitted to the government in June 2016, three months after the Union cabinet hastily approved the details of the scheme in March and a month after Modi formally launched the scheme. It is a beneficiary social welfare scheme introduced by the Narendra Modi Government on 1st May 2016, ahead of assembly polls, from Ballia in Uttar Pradesh. The scheme aimed to replacing the unclean cooking fuels mostly used in rural India with clean and more efficient LPG and aims to provide LPG connections to BPL households in the country. As a freelance writer, the postmortem of the scheme with 20/20 vision conducted and placed in the public domain for general awareness to understand it in a better way than lopsided story in circulation.
The Modi government is merely counting the number of new gas connections provided under Pradhan Mantri Ujjawala Yojna (PMUY) as only yardstick for celebrations without deep routing into the scheme. We can agree that number of connections provided to users under this scheme is enormous but at the same time we too has to admit that consumers of LPG cylinders under this scheme are declining day-to-day after first cylinder exhausts. Growth in the number of LPG customers was the highest in the past decade in 2016-17. PMUY is the reason for this. Out of 32.2 million new LPG connections in 2016-17, twenty million are PMUY beneficiaries. While the number of LPG connections across India has increased by an impressive 16.26% since the scheme was launched, the use of gas cylinders increased by only 9.83%. This is even lower than the rate recorded in 2014-15, when the scheme did not exist, according to data from the government's Petroleum Planning and Analysis Cell and other data accessed by scroll in. There is a huge mismatch in growth of LPG consumption and customers under this scheme. This difference between the increase in the number of connections and the sale of cylinders is a consequence of the fact that many people with new connections are not buying refilled cylinders after their first one runs out. The interesting factor here is that although government has provided a free empty cylinder to 20 million consumers under PMUY but the actual users of the LPG under the scheme are far less than those obtaining the LPG connections. However, statistics from the ministry of petroleum question the euphoria around PMUY. LPG connections have increased no doubt but PMUY beneficiaries do not seem to be using their LPG cylinders. India's poor are not using LPG cylinders they got under Ujjwala scheme. A large number of PMUY beneficiaries have not come back for refills in many states (Oil Minister has projected that as many as four LPG cylinders are bought by about 60 per cent of the 3.2 crore poor women who were given free cooking gas connection). The gap between consumption and customer growth for LPG in 2016-17 confirms the hype of Modi government created about PMUY customers but in actuality not buying refills. There is a huge mismatch in growth of LPG consumption and customers in 2016-17. We find that relatively poorer states such as Bihar, Uttar Pradesh and Madhya Pradesh are the ones with the highest mismatch between sales and customer growth between 2015-16 and 2016-17. A Comptroller and Auditor General's report notes that in 2015-16, households with LPG connections were using an average of 6.27 cylinders in a year. But after the scheme was launched, the number of cylinders used on average had come down to 5.6.
We have an interesting data as to understand why users' not abandoning biomass fuels for cleaner LPG cylinders. CRISIL (formerly Credit Rating Information Services of India Limited) is a global analytical company providing ratings, research, and risk and policy advisory services) that has surveyed more than one lakh people across 120 districts in 13 states prior to implementation of PMUY scheme and results were submitted to the government in June 2016, Meanwhile in a haste government without looking for pros and cons implemented the scheme as a political appeasement to the voters of UP, keeping in mind the elections in the state at door step. Many political analyst credit mass distribution of LPG connections under the scheme, for thumping victory of BJP in UP. The results of various surveys go as; 83% speaks of price of refills was too high, 88% speaks of high recurring monthly expenditure. By contrast, a subsidized LPG cylinder refill costs around Rs 500 and an average family uses around six a year. 72% voted for lack of distributors for the fuel in the local area, long waiting time to get a refill for an empty LPG cylinder as main impediments. Other reasons are; kerosene or firewood is a much cheaper cooking fuel. An average 35% of the households procure firewood for free, 76% got cow-dung cakes for free and 88% obtained other kinds of biomass for free even a subsidized cylinder costs around Rs 496.31 as on date. Paying for one LPG cylinder per month is not an insignificant expenditure for poor households in India.
Who is actual beneficiary then? The scheme provide only free connection and not supply, this doesn't ensure the continuation of use of LPG as many people are too poor to afford. But under the scheme, the government provides immediate a subsidy of Rs 1,600 to government-owned oil manufacturing companies for every free LPG gas connection that they install in poor rural households. This subsidy is intended to cover the security fee for the cylinder and the fitting charges. The target of the government to provide cylinders to 5 crore such household by the end of 2018-19, means an amount of Rs. 8000 crore to the oil companies and it is the tax payers money. The beneficiary has to buy her own cooking stove. To reduce the burden, the scheme allows beneficiaries to pay for the stove and the first refill in monthly installments. However, the cost of all subsequent refills has to be borne by the beneficiary household without any concessions from the second refill. Households though opt for subsidized connections but do not spend on refilling their cylinders as it is costly as compared to biomass thus it would be difficult to sustain it.
Concluding to make the scheme beneficial in real sense government has to concentrate on following suggestions: The cost of refilled cylinders would have to be further subsidized by the government. In addition, the infrastructure for delivering cylinders, dealers and distributors had to be enhanced substantially. This will provide an additional employment and provide business opportunity in businesses ranging from setting up of infrastructure to manufacture cylinders, gas stoves, regulators, and gas hose.
  Share This News with Your Friends on Social Network  
  Comment on this Story  
Early Times Android App
BSE Sensex
NSE Nifty
Home About Us Top Stories Local News National News Sports News Opinion Editorial ET Cetra Advertise with Us ET E-paper
J&K Govt. Official website
Jammu Kashmir Tourism
Mata Vaishnodevi Shrine Board
Shri Amarnath Ji Shrine Board
Shri Shiv Khori Shrine Board
Train Enquiry
Jammu Kashmir Bank
State Bank of India
Passport Department
Income Tax Department
IT Education
Web Site Design Services
Jammu University
Jammu University Results
Kashmir University
IGNOU Jammu Center