x

Like our Facebook Page

   
Early Times Newspaper Jammu, Leading Newspaper Jammu
 
Breaking News :   Terrorist country Pak wants to derail J&K’s development journey: LG Sinha | LG visits Nunwan base camp, interacts with pilgrims, officials, others | RSS to reach every home during centenary year | Op Sindoor led to increase in demand for indigenous defence products: Rajnath Singh | Army, Defence Minister pay tribute to Capt Batra | Azad unofficially disbands DPAP as key leaders desert party! | Pahalgam terror attack: NIA gets custody of 2 accused for 10 more days | Day 5: 23,857 pilgrims pay obeisance, figure crosses 90,000 mark | 3 yatris among 4 injured in Anantnag accident | Court rejects bail of woman involved in terror activities | BSF jawan shoots himself dead | 2 civilians stranded on landslide-hit road rescued | Kashmir: Schools to reopen today | Mission Director HADP inaugurates capacity building programme of FPO’s | Conduct of Medical Patrol for Awam at Songri, Rajouri | Ex-Servicemen Rally, outreach Program conducted | Shri Amar Kshatriya Rajput Sabha holds meeting | Awareness Camp organized under Dharti Aaba Janjatiya Utkarsh Abhiyan | Take Modi government’s 11 years of achievements to every household: Balbir | Empowering Voices of Justice: National Gurjar Advocates Conference held | Two-day Shoulder Rehabilitation workshop organises | DLSA Srinagar organizes awareness programme on drug abuse | Amarnath Yatra a spiritual & religious journey | Invisible Walls | Parched Paradise: Scorching heat dries up Kashmir’s Summer Charm | LG Sinha’s Rallying Call | BNI J&K hosts 4th edition, uniting 300 business leaders from across India, honoring top | One notorious drug peddler nabbed by Jammu Police | Himachal Rains: Rescue Operations On To Trace 30 Missing After Cloudbursts, Landslips In Mandi | Police arrests a drug peddler from Bus Stand | BRO CE calls on Dy CM; discusses road infra in Jammu province | Adityanath pays tributes to Kargil martyr Captain Vikram Batra on death anniversary | Delhi Speaker meets Amit Shah, briefs about ongoing initiatives in Assembly | Youtuber Jyoti Malhotra's Judicial Custody Extended By 14 Days In Espionage Case | ISRO Chief Dr V Narayanan meets CM Yogi, explores dedicated satellite for Uttar Pradesh | 'Approval for Phase IV of the Pradhan Mantri Gram Sadak Yojana will be given as per the state's proposal' - Shri Shivraj Singh | NFR Strengthens Safety Measures for Monsoon Operations | DIG JKS Range Shiv Kumar IPS conduct Security Review | HC dismissed petition with costs Rs 50000 | Elderly man loses Rs 73.72 lakh in gold trading draud after meeting woman on dating app | Luggage packed, will move out of official residence: Ex-CJI DY Chandrachud | Van Mahotsav 2025: Forest Dept to plant 3.5 crore saplings along riverbanks | Shrine Board Judokas to represent India at International Competitions | International recognition of cross-border terrorism validates India's stand: Kavinder Gupta | DC Kulgam takes review of Mission YUVA; assesses implementation, progress | Sheep Husbandry deptt organizes PMFME workshop/awareness programme | ABRSM delegation meets CEO Jammu, highlights teachers' key issues | Macadamization work begins on Tujjar Sharief to Zaingeer road, Baramulla | Over Rs.41 crore allocated under DDC, BDC, PRI & Aspirational Grants in Bandipora | PAC holds meet at Srinagar, discusses Audit Paras of HUDD | J&K Cine Association slams 'Hillywood' label as misleading and politically driven | UP CM orders strict action against those attempting to defile Kanwar Yatra | 5 of family murdered on suspicion of practising witchcraft in Bihar, oppn slams govt | PM Modi at BRICS, a global wake-up call against terrorism: Gaurav Gupta | Shiv Sena distributed poster to Amarnath pilgrims for 'Jammu-Darshan' | SBI hands over Rs 1.10 Crore DSP PAI claim to family of Martyr Rifleman Sunil Kumar | Mission Director HADP inaugurates five-day Capacity Building Programme for FPOs | Beating the heat wave and humidity, IGNOU flying squad teams charge into Exam Centres for on-the-spot monitoring | FVSc and AH, SKUAST-Jammu celebrates World Zoonoses Day- 2025 | Annual congregation of All India Rohmetra Mahajan Biradari on 10th , July | Bovine smuggling attempt foiled, 09 bovines rescued, in Latti | LIC of India introduces new Plans LIC's Nav Jeevan Shree (Plan 912) & LIC's Nav Jeevan Shree Single Premium (Plan 911) | 15-day Youth Development Programme on 'Premier Banker' inaugurates | Mechanical Engineering students of DBU developed "Multi-Utility Power Generating Kit" | 'Kala aur Atmanirbharta' culminates at MCM | Tanvi Sharma eyes junior titles before full-fledged senior switch | JKCCA appoints Dr Rekha Rani Sharma as Advisor | Pinegrove Director elected president BSAI | Aryaveer and Aaryavir: The Kohli, Sehwag connection at this year's DPL | Indian archers eye World Championship preparation at Madrid World Cup | Back Issues  
 
news details
Post-Balakot, Pakistan scrambled jets from 8 bases. Was 10 minutes late: IAF report
4/25/2019 7:19:31 PM
New Delhi
 “The strategic-surprise” of the Balakot airstrikes by the Indian Air Force in the Khyber Phaktunwa region of Pakistan on February 26 was “complete and total” despite Pakistan being on high alert, according to a report on “the lessons learnt” from the operation, which also mentions that five of the six designated targets were hit, the first official acknowledgement of the number of targets.

The report, a detailed assessment of the positives and negatives of the operation, to be used as a reference for future operations, was discussed at a high-level meeting of IAF recently.

On February 26, in response to a suicide bombing attack by a Jaish-e-Mohammed (JeM) terrorist on a CRPF convoy in Pulwama, Jammu and Kashmir, that killed 40 troopers, and to pre-empt more such attacks, IAF struck a training camp of the Pakistan-based JeM in Balakot. There’s been a lot of discussion and debate on the attack, including on the damage inflicted, but the report marks the first time IAF discussed the operation’s effectiveness.


The assessment has revealed several positives, but because “no battle plan ever survives the first contact with the enemy”, there were also deviations from the plan, and some outright negatives too.


The Positives

The “strategic surprise” was so complete that only after IAF’s Mirage-2000s delivered the weapons package and turned back did Pakistan scramble jets from “as many as eight fighter bases”. These included the Pakistan Air Force base Mushaf in Sargoda, Rafiqui in Shorkot, Minhas in Kamra Attock, and Murid in Chakwal. “But the distance between PAF and IAF fighters was at least 10 minutes,” a senior officer in the security establishment said on condition of anonymity.

“Pakistan was expecting a response, but from the PAF response it appears it did not expect us to take the aerial route,” the officer added.

The “accuracy” of intelligence and the subsequent target selection is one of the positives the report talks about. “With this quality of intelligence, we can hit any target inside Pakistan within three hours,” a second senior security establishment official said, asking not to be named.

Among the other positives, the report lists the proficiency and skills of pilots who flew the mission, and describes them as “top class”. Keeping in the tradition of IAF, the Commanding Officers (CO) of the respective squadrons flew the mission. All pilots who flew the mission are likely to be awarded for their skill and ability.

Importantly, although nearly 6,000 men and officers of IAF were involved in the execution – aircraft flew from different airbases spread across India – there were “no leakages”.

Deception at the strategic and tactical level deceived Pakistan, the report says. While Chief of Air Staff BS Dhanoa and the top echelon of IAF went about normal duties — including attending conferences, banquets, and addressing Defence Attaché’s, so-called Combat Air Patrols along the border areas — before the strike lulled Pakistan to some extent.

Importantly, during the attack, a strike-element of Russian made Su-30s flying towards Bahawalpur, Pakistan, where the JeM is based, forced the neighbouring country to divert its energies and air defence capabilities in a separate sector.

Finally, the accuracy of the weapons have also come in for praise in the report. IAF used Spice 2000 precision guided munitions (PGM) to hit the target, among others. “Five of the six designated targets” inside the Jaish-e- Mohammed (JeM) training camp in Balakot were hit directly, the assessment report has concluded.


Cloud cover and weather conditions did create problems for the fighter fleet, the report says. Importantly, the entire weapons package — apart from the Spice 2000 — carried by the IAF fleet wasn’t delivered, leading to questions about to weapon to target matching. Changes in the software made to integrate new weapon systems with vintage Mirage aircraft didn’t completely work.

IAF use indigenous skills to integrate the new weapons systems. “The Balakot experience underlines integration of new weapons with platforms should be done by the Original Equipment Manufacturer (OEM) despite the cost involved,” said a senior official aware of the assessment, who did not want to be named.

The other “negative” listed in the report is in the politico-strategic domain. IAF, when planning the attack, gave priority to eliminating the maximum number of terrorists at the JeM facility. It chose Spice 2000 – a penetration smart bomb – over a fragmentation weapon. The former penetrates structures killing everyone inside whereas the latter flattens and demolishes structures.

“When questions were raised about the strike, especially internationally, IAF didn’t have much by way of pictures to show as evidence making it easy for Pakistan to deny the attack itself,” a third senior officer in the security establishment said, asking not to be identified.


Looking ahead and taking the lessons from the Balakot strike, IAF wants more “technological asymmetry” to be able to “penetrate the enemy airspace at will”, according to the report. It will be looking at better air defence capabilities. The induction of new platforms such as the Russian made S-400 surface to air anti-aircraft missile systems will fill part of the gap.

According to a former senior air force official, India should concentrate on absorbing more defence technology. “Technological asymmetry will always give you an edge over the enemy. However, if the OEM [original equipment manufacturer, or the supplier] is the same on either, it could create difficulties,” said former Air Vice Marshal Sunil Jayant Nanodkar.

“We achieved complete surprise and the mission was successful. It highlights the need to give forces the freedom to execute a political decision. The execution of a political decision should be at choosing of the forces,” he added.
  Share This News with Your Friends on Social Network  
  Comment on this Story  
 
 
 
Early Times Android App
STOCK UPDATE
  
BSE Sensex
NSE Nifty
 
CRICKET UPDATE
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
   
Home About Us Top Stories Local News National News Sports News Opinion Editorial ET Cetra Advertise with Us ET E-paper
 
 
J&K RELATED WEBSITES
J&K Govt. Official website
Jammu Kashmir Tourism
JKTDC
Mata Vaishnodevi Shrine Board
Shri Amarnath Ji Shrine Board
Shri Shiv Khori Shrine Board
UTILITY
Train Enquiry
IRCTC
Matavaishnodevi
BSNL
Jammu Kashmir Bank
State Bank of India
PUBLIC INTEREST
Passport Department
Income Tax Department
JK CAMPA
JK GAD
IT Education
Web Site Design Services
EDUCATION
Jammu University
Jammu University Results
JKBOSE
Kashmir University
IGNOU Jammu Center
SMVDU