x

Like our Facebook Page

   
Early Times Newspaper Jammu, Leading Newspaper Jammu
 
Breaking News :   Kulgam Encounter: Probe finds slain terrorist sheltered LeT commander months before joining terror ranks | CRPF personnel directed not to use mobile phones while on duty | JKSSB officials under scanner after cheating racket busted in FAA exam | Development shall not be restricted to main cities, major towns only: CM Omar | Conservation boost: Ladakh's black-necked crane population jumps 25% in a year | Father younger than son: HC refuses to quash cheating, corruption case against two doctors | Mere duty certificate no ground to quash FIR: High Court | Crime Branch files chargesheet against man for securing job using fake certificate | ACB chargesheets former TSO, storekeeper, 13 dealers | CRPF Special DG visits Srinagar Headquarters, reviews operations | Srinagar records season's first sub-zero night | Hardeep Puri takes oath as Rajya Sabha member | Govt hikes windfall gains tax on diesel | Punjab Police recover 39-Kg Heroin haul | Artificial intelligence Vs actual intelligence | From Crop waste to Green innovation: Punjab farmer develops fireproof ceiling tiles from paddy stubble | Remain Alert To Divisive Influences | High Court sets aside conviction in 20-year-old forest assault case | JMC Commissioner inspects wards 20, 21 and 22, reviews development works and interacts with public | Cancellation of Train Nos. 14695 and 14696 During the Foggy Season | Yasha Mudgal reviews PACS computerisation, CAPEX expenditure; stresses timely execution | Samba police solved theft case; accused arrested, stolen items alongwith cash recovered | Northeast India's journey from zero to 100% Railway Electrification in 10 years | HC upholds bail rejection of two accused in alleged JKLF revival conspiracy | Awantipora police hosts farewell function in honour of transferred DySPs | JKNC OBC Cell chairman Abdul Gani Telli receives warm welcome | Doda police seized tipper carrying Bajri without e-challan at Thathri | Reasi police takes swift action on viral video of pony workers assaulting fellow worker on SMVD track | Raksha Mantri to attend 4th India-Japan 2+2 ministerial dialogue and hold bilateral talks with his Japanese counterpart in Tokyo | MP (RS) Er GA Khatana pays glowing tributes to great freedom fighter and tribal leader | Monumental milestone for Ladakh as black-necked crane population reaches 108 in 2026, registering 25% rise from 2025 | SSP Ramban chairs security and crime review meeting | Reasi police recovers 124 grams of Heroin in Katra; three arrested | Khet Bachao Abhiyan organised at KVK Reasi to promote natural farming | Shiv Sena pays tribute to Balasaheb Thackeray; opens Anantnag office | MCM welcomes NCC Group Commander Brigadier Ashish Maini | Grand Gopashtami Mahotsav celebrated with religious fervour at Jai Maa Surbhi Gaushala, Akhnoor | J&K Sports Council’s continuous support and commitment to grassroots sports appreciated as district Kupwara | Grand inauguration of the 67th Foundation Week of Pantnagar University | Back Issues  
 
news details
Inconsistent judicial decisions shake public trust: SC
4/29/2025 10:48:05 PM
New Delhi, Apr 29:
Agencies

The Supreme Court on Tuesday observed inconsistent decisions from different benches shook public trust and outlined their consistency to be hallmark of a responsible judiciary. A bench of Justices P S Narasimha and Joymalya Bagchi was hearing a matrimonial matter where two different single benches of Karnataka High Court had passed contradictory verdicts.
“The case at hand portrays a disturbing picture. While one judge refused to quash proceeding against the in-laws, inter alia, observing the wound certificate demonstrates the appellant was assaulted and suffered simple injuries, another judge by the impugned order quashed the proceeding against respondent husband holding the medical certificate was not consistent with the allegations in the complaint, i.e., the wound certificate does not show the injuries were caused by a blunt weapon.”
Justice Bagchi, who authored the verdict, censured the order passed by the second judge, who quashed the proceedings against the husband.
“Having perused the impugned judgment, we are of the view the judge erred in law by embarking upon an enquiry with regard to the credibility or otherwise of the allegations in the FIR/chargesheet.”
The top court opined the judge compared the nature of assault described in the FIR in relation to the wound certificate and held the allegations to be untrue.
In the process, the bench said, the judge performed a mini-trial to quash the proceeding -- an exercise impermissible in law.
The top court said though the order refusing to quash the proceeding against some of the in-laws was passed earlier, it was inexplicable why it did not find a mention in the order quashing the proceedings against the husband.
“It was incumbent on the judge while quashing the proceeding against the respondent husband to refer to the earlier decision of the co-ordinate bench and distinguish the reasons therein to arrive at a different conclusion. Failure to do so infracts judicial propriety and discipline,” the bench said.
Consistency in judicial outcomes, it underscored, was the hallmark of a responsible judiciary.
“Inconsistent decisions coming out from different benches shake public trust and reduce litigation to a punter’s game. It gives rise to various insidious sharp practices like forum shopping spoiling the clear stream of justice.”
The top court said the high court judge “misdirected himself” in holding that the proceeding was malicious and an abuse of the process of the court as the matter was pending in the matrimonial court.
“Offences involving cruelty on wife would invariably arise out of matrimonial disputes,” it added.
The bench said the impugned order suffered from the “vice of judicial caprice” and deserved to be set aside.
Notably, the top court said the pendency of the matrimonial case couldn’t per se lead to an inference that institution of criminal proceeding alleging assault supported by medical evidence and independent witness was a “product of malice and abuse of the court”.
The bench said it was nobody’s case that no injury was noted in the wound certificate thereby rendering the allegation of assault patently absurd or inherently improbable.
“In this backdrop, it was unwarranted for the judge to embark on a mini trial to weigh the ocular version vis-à-vis medical evidence and quash the proceeding. Whether the ocular evidence is fully incompatible with medical evidence is a matter of trial and cannot be a ground to terminate prosecution at the initial stage,” it added.
The top court’s order came on a plea of the wife against the high court order quashing the criminal case against her estranged husband.
She alleged her estranged husband had an affair with another woman and the latter verbally abused her.
Her estranged husband and in-laws, she alleged further, harassed her physically and mentally aside from demanding a Rs 2-lakh dowry.
Owing to the ill-treatment meted out to her and the dowry demand, she moved in with her parents.
The case was lodged against the husband and in-laws over charges of assault and dowry harassment.
The husband and others moved the high court seeking quashing ofthe FIR.
  Share This News with Your Friends on Social Network  
  Comment on this Story  
 
 
 
Early Times Android App
STOCK UPDATE
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
   
Home About Us Top Stories Local News National News Sports News Opinion Editorial ET Cetra Advertise with Us ET E-paper
 
 
J&K RELATED WEBSITES
J&K Govt. Official website
Jammu Kashmir Tourism
JKTDC
Mata Vaishnodevi Shrine Board
Shri Amarnath Ji Shrine Board
Shri Shiv Khori Shrine Board
UTILITY
Train Enquiry
IRCTC
Matavaishnodevi
BSNL
Jammu Kashmir Bank
State Bank of India
PUBLIC INTEREST
Passport Department
Income Tax Department
JK CAMPA
JK GAD
IT Education
Web Site Design Services
EDUCATION
Jammu University
Jammu University Results
JKBOSE
Kashmir University
IGNOU Jammu Center
SMVDU